Amy J. McMichael, MD

Hidradenitis suppurativa (HS)—a chronic, relapsing, inflammatory disorder involving terminal hair follicles in apocrine gland–rich skin—manifests as tender inflamed nodules that transform into abscesses, sinus tracts, and scarring.^1,2 The etiology of HS is multifactorial, encompassing lifestyle, microbiota, hormonal status, and genetic and environmental factors. These factors activate the immune system around the terminal hair follicles and lead to hyperkeratosis of the infundibulum of the hair follicles in intertriginous regions. This progresses to follicular occlusion, stasis, and eventual rupture. Bacterial multiplication within the plugged pilosebaceous units further boosts immune activation. Resident and migrated cells of the innate and adaptive immune system then release proinflammatory cytokines such as tumor necrosis factor, IL-1β, and IL-17, which further enhance immune cell influx and inflammation.^3,4 This aberrant immune response propagates the production of deep-seated inflammatory nodules and abscesses.^3-8

The estimated prevalence of HS is 1% worldwide.⁹ It is more prevalent in female and Black patients (0.30%) than White patients (0.09%) and is intermediate in prevalence in the biracial population (0.22%).¹⁰ Hidradenitis suppurativa is thought to be associated with lower socioeconomic status (SES). In a retrospective analysis of HS patients (N=375), approximately one-third of patients were Black, had advanced disease, and had a notably lower SES.¹¹ Furthermore, HS has been reported to be associated with systemic inflammation and comorbidities such as morbid obesity (38.3%) and hypertension (39.6%) as well as other metabolic syndrome–related disorders and depression (48.1%).¹

Hidradenitis suppurativa may contribute to the risk for depression through its substantial impact on health-related quality of life, which culminates in social withdrawal, unemployment, and suicidal thoughts.¹² The high prevalence of depression in individuals with HS¹ and its association with systemic inflammation¹³ increases the likelihood that a common genetic predisposition also may exist between both conditions. Because depression frequently has been discovered as a concomitant diagnosis in patients with HS, we hypothesize that a shared genetic susceptibility also may exist between the 2 disorders. Our study sought to explore data on the co-occurrence of depression with HS, including its demographics and racial data.

Methods

We conducted a PubMed search of articles indexed for MEDLINE as well as Google Scholar using the terms depression and hidradenitis suppurativa to obtain all research articles published from 2000 to 2022. Articles were selected based on relevance to the topic of exploration. English-language articles that directly addressed the epidemiology, etiology, pathophysiology, and co-occurrence of both depression and HS with numerical data were included. Articles were excluded if they did not explore the information of interest on these 2 disorders or did not contain clear statistical data of patients with the 2 concurrent medical conditions.

Results

Twenty-two cross-sectional, prospective, and retrospective studies that fit the search criteria were identified and included in the analysis (eTable).^1,14-34 Sixteen (72.7%) studies were cross-sectional, 5 (22.7%) were retrospective, and only 1 (4.5%) was a prospective study. Only 6 of the studies provided racial data,^{1,14,17,26,28,32} and of them, 4 had predominately White patients,^1,14,26,32 whereas the other 2 had predominantly Black patients.^17,28

Hidradenitis suppurativa was found to coexist with depression in all the studies, with a prevalence of 1.2% to 48.1%. There also was a higher prevalence of depression in HS patients than in the control patients without HS. Furthermore, a recent study by Wright and colleagues¹⁴ stratified the depression prevalence data by age and found a higher prevalence of depression in adults vs children with HS (30% vs 12%).

Comment

Major depression—a chronic and debilitating illness—is the chief cause of disability globally and in the United States alone and has a global lifetime prevalence of 17%.³⁵ In a study of 388 patients diagnosed with depression and 404 community-matched controls who were observed for 10 years, depressed patients had a two-thirds higher likelihood of developing a serious physical illness than controls. The depression-associated elevated risk for serious physical illness persisted after controlling for confounding variables such as alcohol abuse, smoking, and level of physical activity.³⁶ Studies also have demonstrated that HS is more prevalent in Black individuals¹⁰ and in individuals of low SES,³⁷ who are mostly the Black and Hispanic populations that experience the highest burden of racial microaggression³⁸ and disparities in health access and outcomes.^39,40 The severity and chronicity of major depressive disorder also is higher in Black patients compared with White patients (57% vs 39%).⁴¹ Because major depression and HS are most common among Black patients who experience the highest-burden negative financial and health disparities, there may be a shared genetic disposition to both medical conditions.

Moreover, the common detrimental lifestyle choices associated with patients with depression and HS also suggest the possibility of a collective genetic susceptibility. Patients with depression also report increased consumption of alcohol, tobacco, and illicit substances; sedentary lifestyle leading to obesity; and poor compliance with prescribed medical treatment.⁴² Smoking and obesity are known contributors to the pathogenesis of HS, and their modification also is known to positively impact the disease course. In a retrospective single-cohort study, 50% of obese HS patients (n=35) reported a substantial decrease in disease severity after a reduction of more than 15% in body mass index over 2 years following bariatric surgery (n=35).⁴³ Patients with HS also have reported disease remission following extensive weight loss.⁴⁴ In addition, evidence has supported smoking cessation in improving the disease course of HS.⁴³ Because these detrimental lifestyle choices are prevalent in both patients with HS and those with depression, a co-genetic susceptibility also may exist.

Furthermore, depression is characterized by a persistent inflammatory state,^13,45 similar to HS.⁴⁶ Elevated levels of a variety of inflammatory markers, such as C-reactive protein (CRP), IL-6, and soluble intercellular adhesion molecule 1, have been reported in patients with depression compared with healthy controls.^13,45 Further analysis found a positive correlation and a strong association between depression and these inflammatory markers.⁴⁷ Moreover, adipokines regulate inflammatory responses, and adipokines play a role in the pathogenesis of HS. Adipokine levels such as elevated omentin-1 (a recently identified adipokine) were found to be altered in patients with HS compared with controls.⁴⁸ Results from clinical studies and meta-analyses of patients with depression also have demonstrated that adipokines are dysregulated in this population,^49,50 which may be another potential genetic link between depression and HS.

In addition, genetic susceptibility to depression and HS may be shared because the inflammatory markers that have a strong association with depression also have been found to play an important role in HS treatment and disease severity prediction. In a retrospective cohort study of 404 patients, CRP or IL-6 levels were found to be reliable predictors of HS disease severity, which may explain why anti–tumor necrosis factor antibody regimens such as adalimumab and infliximab have clinically ameliorated disease activity in several cases of HS.⁵¹ In a study evaluating these drugs, high baseline levels of high-sensitivity CRP and IL-6 were predictive of patient response to infliximab.⁵² In a meta-analysis evaluating 20,791 participants, an association was found between concurrent depression and CRP. Furthermore, inflammation measured by high levels of CRP or IL-6 was observed to predict future depression.⁵³ If the same inflammatory markers—CRP and IL-6—both play a major role in the disease activity of depression and HS, then a concurrent genetic predisposition may exist.

Conclusion

Understanding the comorbidities, etiologies, and risk factors for the development and progression of HS is an important step toward improved disease management. Available studies on comorbid depression in HS largely involve White patients, and more studies are needed in patients with skin of color, particularly the Black population, who have the highest prevalence of HS.¹⁰ Given the evidence for an association between depression and HS, we suggest a large-scale investigation of this patient population that includes a complete medical history, onset of HS in comparison to the onset of depression, and specific measures of disease progress and lifetime management of depression, which may help to increase knowledge about the role of depression in HS and encourage more research in this area. If shared genetic susceptibility is established, aggressive management of depression in patients at risk for HS may reduce disease incidence and severity as well as the psychological burden on patients.

Hidradenitis suppurativa (HS)—a chronic, relapsing, inflammatory disorder involving terminal hair follicles in apocrine gland–rich skin—manifests as tender inflamed nodules that transform into abscesses, sinus tracts, and scarring.^1,2 The etiology of HS is multifactorial, encompassing lifestyle, microbiota, hormonal status, and genetic and environmental factors. These factors activate the immune system around the terminal hair follicles and lead to hyperkeratosis of the infundibulum of the hair follicles in intertriginous regions. This progresses to follicular occlusion, stasis, and eventual rupture. Bacterial multiplication within the plugged pilosebaceous units further boosts immune activation. Resident and migrated cells of the innate and adaptive immune system then release proinflammatory cytokines such as tumor necrosis factor, IL-1β, and IL-17, which further enhance immune cell influx and inflammation.^3,4 This aberrant immune response propagates the production of deep-seated inflammatory nodules and abscesses.^3-8

The estimated prevalence of HS is 1% worldwide.⁹ It is more prevalent in female and Black patients (0.30%) than White patients (0.09%) and is intermediate in prevalence in the biracial population (0.22%).¹⁰ Hidradenitis suppurativa is thought to be associated with lower socioeconomic status (SES). In a retrospective analysis of HS patients (N=375), approximately one-third of patients were Black, had advanced disease, and had a notably lower SES.¹¹ Furthermore, HS has been reported to be associated with systemic inflammation and comorbidities such as morbid obesity (38.3%) and hypertension (39.6%) as well as other metabolic syndrome–related disorders and depression (48.1%).¹

Hidradenitis suppurativa may contribute to the risk for depression through its substantial impact on health-related quality of life, which culminates in social withdrawal, unemployment, and suicidal thoughts.¹² The high prevalence of depression in individuals with HS¹ and its association with systemic inflammation¹³ increases the likelihood that a common genetic predisposition also may exist between both conditions. Because depression frequently has been discovered as a concomitant diagnosis in patients with HS, we hypothesize that a shared genetic susceptibility also may exist between the 2 disorders. Our study sought to explore data on the co-occurrence of depression with HS, including its demographics and racial data.

Methods

We conducted a PubMed search of articles indexed for MEDLINE as well as Google Scholar using the terms depression and hidradenitis suppurativa to obtain all research articles published from 2000 to 2022. Articles were selected based on relevance to the topic of exploration. English-language articles that directly addressed the epidemiology, etiology, pathophysiology, and co-occurrence of both depression and HS with numerical data were included. Articles were excluded if they did not explore the information of interest on these 2 disorders or did not contain clear statistical data of patients with the 2 concurrent medical conditions.

Results

Twenty-two cross-sectional, prospective, and retrospective studies that fit the search criteria were identified and included in the analysis (eTable).^1,14-34 Sixteen (72.7%) studies were cross-sectional, 5 (22.7%) were retrospective, and only 1 (4.5%) was a prospective study. Only 6 of the studies provided racial data,^{1,14,17,26,28,32} and of them, 4 had predominately White patients,^1,14,26,32 whereas the other 2 had predominantly Black patients.^17,28

Hidradenitis suppurativa was found to coexist with depression in all the studies, with a prevalence of 1.2% to 48.1%. There also was a higher prevalence of depression in HS patients than in the control patients without HS. Furthermore, a recent study by Wright and colleagues¹⁴ stratified the depression prevalence data by age and found a higher prevalence of depression in adults vs children with HS (30% vs 12%).

Comment

Major depression—a chronic and debilitating illness—is the chief cause of disability globally and in the United States alone and has a global lifetime prevalence of 17%.³⁵ In a study of 388 patients diagnosed with depression and 404 community-matched controls who were observed for 10 years, depressed patients had a two-thirds higher likelihood of developing a serious physical illness than controls. The depression-associated elevated risk for serious physical illness persisted after controlling for confounding variables such as alcohol abuse, smoking, and level of physical activity.³⁶ Studies also have demonstrated that HS is more prevalent in Black individuals¹⁰ and in individuals of low SES,³⁷ who are mostly the Black and Hispanic populations that experience the highest burden of racial microaggression³⁸ and disparities in health access and outcomes.^39,40 The severity and chronicity of major depressive disorder also is higher in Black patients compared with White patients (57% vs 39%).⁴¹ Because major depression and HS are most common among Black patients who experience the highest-burden negative financial and health disparities, there may be a shared genetic disposition to both medical conditions.

Moreover, the common detrimental lifestyle choices associated with patients with depression and HS also suggest the possibility of a collective genetic susceptibility. Patients with depression also report increased consumption of alcohol, tobacco, and illicit substances; sedentary lifestyle leading to obesity; and poor compliance with prescribed medical treatment.⁴² Smoking and obesity are known contributors to the pathogenesis of HS, and their modification also is known to positively impact the disease course. In a retrospective single-cohort study, 50% of obese HS patients (n=35) reported a substantial decrease in disease severity after a reduction of more than 15% in body mass index over 2 years following bariatric surgery (n=35).⁴³ Patients with HS also have reported disease remission following extensive weight loss.⁴⁴ In addition, evidence has supported smoking cessation in improving the disease course of HS.⁴³ Because these detrimental lifestyle choices are prevalent in both patients with HS and those with depression, a co-genetic susceptibility also may exist.

Furthermore, depression is characterized by a persistent inflammatory state,^13,45 similar to HS.⁴⁶ Elevated levels of a variety of inflammatory markers, such as C-reactive protein (CRP), IL-6, and soluble intercellular adhesion molecule 1, have been reported in patients with depression compared with healthy controls.^13,45 Further analysis found a positive correlation and a strong association between depression and these inflammatory markers.⁴⁷ Moreover, adipokines regulate inflammatory responses, and adipokines play a role in the pathogenesis of HS. Adipokine levels such as elevated omentin-1 (a recently identified adipokine) were found to be altered in patients with HS compared with controls.⁴⁸ Results from clinical studies and meta-analyses of patients with depression also have demonstrated that adipokines are dysregulated in this population,^49,50 which may be another potential genetic link between depression and HS.

In addition, genetic susceptibility to depression and HS may be shared because the inflammatory markers that have a strong association with depression also have been found to play an important role in HS treatment and disease severity prediction. In a retrospective cohort study of 404 patients, CRP or IL-6 levels were found to be reliable predictors of HS disease severity, which may explain why anti–tumor necrosis factor antibody regimens such as adalimumab and infliximab have clinically ameliorated disease activity in several cases of HS.⁵¹ In a study evaluating these drugs, high baseline levels of high-sensitivity CRP and IL-6 were predictive of patient response to infliximab.⁵² In a meta-analysis evaluating 20,791 participants, an association was found between concurrent depression and CRP. Furthermore, inflammation measured by high levels of CRP or IL-6 was observed to predict future depression.⁵³ If the same inflammatory markers—CRP and IL-6—both play a major role in the disease activity of depression and HS, then a concurrent genetic predisposition may exist.

Conclusion

Understanding the comorbidities, etiologies, and risk factors for the development and progression of HS is an important step toward improved disease management. Available studies on comorbid depression in HS largely involve White patients, and more studies are needed in patients with skin of color, particularly the Black population, who have the highest prevalence of HS.¹⁰ Given the evidence for an association between depression and HS, we suggest a large-scale investigation of this patient population that includes a complete medical history, onset of HS in comparison to the onset of depression, and specific measures of disease progress and lifetime management of depression, which may help to increase knowledge about the role of depression in HS and encourage more research in this area. If shared genetic susceptibility is established, aggressive management of depression in patients at risk for HS may reduce disease incidence and severity as well as the psychological burden on patients.

Hidradenitis suppurativa (HS)—a chronic, relapsing, inflammatory disorder involving terminal hair follicles in apocrine gland–rich skin—manifests as tender inflamed nodules that transform into abscesses, sinus tracts, and scarring.^1,2 The etiology of HS is multifactorial, encompassing lifestyle, microbiota, hormonal status, and genetic and environmental factors. These factors activate the immune system around the terminal hair follicles and lead to hyperkeratosis of the infundibulum of the hair follicles in intertriginous regions. This progresses to follicular occlusion, stasis, and eventual rupture. Bacterial multiplication within the plugged pilosebaceous units further boosts immune activation. Resident and migrated cells of the innate and adaptive immune system then release proinflammatory cytokines such as tumor necrosis factor, IL-1β, and IL-17, which further enhance immune cell influx and inflammation.^3,4 This aberrant immune response propagates the production of deep-seated inflammatory nodules and abscesses.^3-8

The estimated prevalence of HS is 1% worldwide.⁹ It is more prevalent in female and Black patients (0.30%) than White patients (0.09%) and is intermediate in prevalence in the biracial population (0.22%).¹⁰ Hidradenitis suppurativa is thought to be associated with lower socioeconomic status (SES). In a retrospective analysis of HS patients (N=375), approximately one-third of patients were Black, had advanced disease, and had a notably lower SES.¹¹ Furthermore, HS has been reported to be associated with systemic inflammation and comorbidities such as morbid obesity (38.3%) and hypertension (39.6%) as well as other metabolic syndrome–related disorders and depression (48.1%).¹

Hidradenitis suppurativa may contribute to the risk for depression through its substantial impact on health-related quality of life, which culminates in social withdrawal, unemployment, and suicidal thoughts.¹² The high prevalence of depression in individuals with HS¹ and its association with systemic inflammation¹³ increases the likelihood that a common genetic predisposition also may exist between both conditions. Because depression frequently has been discovered as a concomitant diagnosis in patients with HS, we hypothesize that a shared genetic susceptibility also may exist between the 2 disorders. Our study sought to explore data on the co-occurrence of depression with HS, including its demographics and racial data.

Methods

We conducted a PubMed search of articles indexed for MEDLINE as well as Google Scholar using the terms depression and hidradenitis suppurativa to obtain all research articles published from 2000 to 2022. Articles were selected based on relevance to the topic of exploration. English-language articles that directly addressed the epidemiology, etiology, pathophysiology, and co-occurrence of both depression and HS with numerical data were included. Articles were excluded if they did not explore the information of interest on these 2 disorders or did not contain clear statistical data of patients with the 2 concurrent medical conditions.

Results

Twenty-two cross-sectional, prospective, and retrospective studies that fit the search criteria were identified and included in the analysis (eTable).^1,14-34 Sixteen (72.7%) studies were cross-sectional, 5 (22.7%) were retrospective, and only 1 (4.5%) was a prospective study. Only 6 of the studies provided racial data,^{1,14,17,26,28,32} and of them, 4 had predominately White patients,^1,14,26,32 whereas the other 2 had predominantly Black patients.^17,28

Hidradenitis suppurativa was found to coexist with depression in all the studies, with a prevalence of 1.2% to 48.1%. There also was a higher prevalence of depression in HS patients than in the control patients without HS. Furthermore, a recent study by Wright and colleagues¹⁴ stratified the depression prevalence data by age and found a higher prevalence of depression in adults vs children with HS (30% vs 12%).

Comment

Major depression—a chronic and debilitating illness—is the chief cause of disability globally and in the United States alone and has a global lifetime prevalence of 17%.³⁵ In a study of 388 patients diagnosed with depression and 404 community-matched controls who were observed for 10 years, depressed patients had a two-thirds higher likelihood of developing a serious physical illness than controls. The depression-associated elevated risk for serious physical illness persisted after controlling for confounding variables such as alcohol abuse, smoking, and level of physical activity.³⁶ Studies also have demonstrated that HS is more prevalent in Black individuals¹⁰ and in individuals of low SES,³⁷ who are mostly the Black and Hispanic populations that experience the highest burden of racial microaggression³⁸ and disparities in health access and outcomes.^39,40 The severity and chronicity of major depressive disorder also is higher in Black patients compared with White patients (57% vs 39%).⁴¹ Because major depression and HS are most common among Black patients who experience the highest-burden negative financial and health disparities, there may be a shared genetic disposition to both medical conditions.

Moreover, the common detrimental lifestyle choices associated with patients with depression and HS also suggest the possibility of a collective genetic susceptibility. Patients with depression also report increased consumption of alcohol, tobacco, and illicit substances; sedentary lifestyle leading to obesity; and poor compliance with prescribed medical treatment.⁴² Smoking and obesity are known contributors to the pathogenesis of HS, and their modification also is known to positively impact the disease course. In a retrospective single-cohort study, 50% of obese HS patients (n=35) reported a substantial decrease in disease severity after a reduction of more than 15% in body mass index over 2 years following bariatric surgery (n=35).⁴³ Patients with HS also have reported disease remission following extensive weight loss.⁴⁴ In addition, evidence has supported smoking cessation in improving the disease course of HS.⁴³ Because these detrimental lifestyle choices are prevalent in both patients with HS and those with depression, a co-genetic susceptibility also may exist.

Furthermore, depression is characterized by a persistent inflammatory state,^13,45 similar to HS.⁴⁶ Elevated levels of a variety of inflammatory markers, such as C-reactive protein (CRP), IL-6, and soluble intercellular adhesion molecule 1, have been reported in patients with depression compared with healthy controls.^13,45 Further analysis found a positive correlation and a strong association between depression and these inflammatory markers.⁴⁷ Moreover, adipokines regulate inflammatory responses, and adipokines play a role in the pathogenesis of HS. Adipokine levels such as elevated omentin-1 (a recently identified adipokine) were found to be altered in patients with HS compared with controls.⁴⁸ Results from clinical studies and meta-analyses of patients with depression also have demonstrated that adipokines are dysregulated in this population,^49,50 which may be another potential genetic link between depression and HS.

In addition, genetic susceptibility to depression and HS may be shared because the inflammatory markers that have a strong association with depression also have been found to play an important role in HS treatment and disease severity prediction. In a retrospective cohort study of 404 patients, CRP or IL-6 levels were found to be reliable predictors of HS disease severity, which may explain why anti–tumor necrosis factor antibody regimens such as adalimumab and infliximab have clinically ameliorated disease activity in several cases of HS.⁵¹ In a study evaluating these drugs, high baseline levels of high-sensitivity CRP and IL-6 were predictive of patient response to infliximab.⁵² In a meta-analysis evaluating 20,791 participants, an association was found between concurrent depression and CRP. Furthermore, inflammation measured by high levels of CRP or IL-6 was observed to predict future depression.⁵³ If the same inflammatory markers—CRP and IL-6—both play a major role in the disease activity of depression and HS, then a concurrent genetic predisposition may exist.

Conclusion

Understanding the comorbidities, etiologies, and risk factors for the development and progression of HS is an important step toward improved disease management. Available studies on comorbid depression in HS largely involve White patients, and more studies are needed in patients with skin of color, particularly the Black population, who have the highest prevalence of HS.¹⁰ Given the evidence for an association between depression and HS, we suggest a large-scale investigation of this patient population that includes a complete medical history, onset of HS in comparison to the onset of depression, and specific measures of disease progress and lifetime management of depression, which may help to increase knowledge about the role of depression in HS and encourage more research in this area. If shared genetic susceptibility is established, aggressive management of depression in patients at risk for HS may reduce disease incidence and severity as well as the psychological burden on patients.

With the introduction of the first US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)–approved medication for alopecia areata (AA)—the Janus kinase (JAK) inhibitor, baricitinib—there is an important focus on this disease in the literature and for practicing dermatologists. Known by all as an autoimmune genetic disease that causes relapsing and remitting nonscarring hair loss, AA is a condition where the psychological burden has been less widely recognized. Patients with AA have reported lower health-related quality of life scores compared to patients with other skin conditions, including psoriasis or atopic dermatitis. In addition, a lesser amount of scalp coverage is negatively correlated to health-related quality of life scores.¹ Patients with AA also have a 39% lifetime prevalence of major depressive disorder and generalized anxiety disorder.² The treatment of AA has been a hodgepodge of topical, intralesional, and systemic agents, all with indirect immunosuppressive or anagen prolongation effects. Now that there is an approved therapy for AA with more treatments likely to be approved in the near future, there must be a focus on real-world outcomes. With the dawn of a new era in the treatment of AA as well as new information showcasing an altered prevalence of AA in skin of color, highlighting disparities among this population may help ease challenges dermatologic providers will face.

Efficacy of Baricitinib in Different Races and Ethnicities

How will patients of different races and ethnicities respond to this new treatment, and how will their emotional health be affected? The 2 phase 3 pivotal trials showing efficacy of baricitinib in AA included Black and Latino patients but not in a way that is representative of the US population.³ Until recently, the most commonly used prevalence of AA in the United States was from the NHANES I study completed between 1971 and 1974, which was between 0.1% and 0.2%⁴ with minimal focus on race and ethnicity. Recent studies suggest that there may be increased prevalence of this condition in Black patients in the United States. These new findings raise concern around access to care and treatment and the need to tailor psychosocial interventions for populations that may not currently have these supports.

A large cross-sectional study published in 2020 demonstrated that these data remained similar, with a lifetime prevalence of 0.21%.⁵ Of the 45,016 participants—representative of the US population based on the 2015 US Census—the average age of AA patients was 41.2 years, with 61.3% being White and not of Hispanic origin.⁵ In recent years, other studies have challenged the narrative that AA predominantly affects White patients.^6-8 A different cross-sectional study utilizing National Alopecia Areata Registry data from 2002 to 2016 suggested that Black patients have greater odds of developing AA.⁶ In this study of 2645 cases of AA, the odds ratios of developing the condition were 1.36 for Blacks, 0.53 for Asians, and 0.83 for Hispanics compared with the referent White population. These results were consistent through the varying subtypes of AA.⁶ In a reply to these findings, Gonzalez and Fleischer⁷ analyzed data from the 2007 to 2016 National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey database with a focus on racial and ethnic prevalence of AA. This study concluded that Latino and non-White individuals had an increased likelihood of clinician visits for AA compared with White individuals.⁷

More evidence of the Black predominance of AA was demonstrated in a study published in 2018. In this large-scale study, 63,960 women from the Nurses’ Health Study (NHS) and 88,368 women from the Nurses’ Health Study II (NHSII) were included to examine prevalence of disease among these US women.⁸ Analysis showed increased odds of AA based on self-reported race in Black and Hispanic women. Lifetime incidence of AA was greater in Black women, with 2.63 and 5.23 in NHS and NHSII, respectively. It was hypothesized that hairstyling practices in Black and Hispanic women may cause AA to be more noticeable,⁸ which may drive patients to seek medical evaluation.

Feaster and McMichael⁹ published information on the epidemiology of AA in a busy hair loss clinic. This retrospective single-institution study of 265 pediatric and adult Black patients with AA seen over a 5-year period showed that patients aged 18 to 34 years were most likely to present for care, which accounted for 35.8% of the study population, followed by patients aged 10 to 17 years, which accounted for 15.1%. This study also found that females were the larger segment of AA patients, with an increased distribution of disease in young patients. Most of these patients (68.2%) had patchy hair loss, and the ophiasis pattern was seen in 15.1%.⁹ Although the pathogenesis of AA is linked to autoimmunity,¹⁰ the leading cause for these epidemiologic findings of increased prevalence in Black patients is still uncertain.

Baricitinib for AA

In June 2022, the FDA announced the first biologic drug approved for the treatment of AA—baricitinib. Baricitinib is an oral, selective, reversible inhibitor of JAK1 and JAK2.³ The phase 3 trials for baricitinib—BRAVE-AA1 (N=654) and BRAVE-AA2 (N=546)—were conducted between March 2019 and May 2020. In these double-blind, parallel-group, randomized, placebo-controlled trials, 33% of the patient population receiving baricitinib accomplished 80% or more scalp coverage at 36 weeks. The Severity of Alopecia Tool (SALT) score also decreased to 20 or less in 36 weeks. The BRAVE-AA1 and BRAVE-AA2 trials consisted of a total of 1200 patients, with only 98 identifying as Black. Of these 98 patients, 33 were randomly selected to receive placebo.³ With studies now suggesting that Black individuals have greater odds of AA compared with White individuals⁶ and Black patients being more likely to seek medical care for AA,⁷ the BRAVE-AA1 and BRAVE-AA2 study population did not allow for significant comparative data for Black patients. These studies did not document Latino patient involvement.³ Future studies in AA must recruit a diversified group of study participants to better reflect the patients with an increased likelihood of presenting with AA.

Other Treatments on the Horizon

Baricitinib likely will remain alone in its class for only a short time. Phase 3 trials have been completed for ritlecitinib, brepocitinib, and deuruxolitinib for AA. Ritlecitinib, an irreversible inhibitor of JAK3 and the tyrosine kinase expressed in hepatocellular carcinoma (TEC) kinase family, has met all end points in a phase 2b/3 study.¹¹ Brepocitinib is an oral tyrosine kinase 2/JAK1 inhibitor,¹² and deuruxolitinib is an investigational JAK1/2 inhibitor for AA.¹³

Prior authorizations have been the initial step for many drugs in varying fields of medical practice. A study completed in 2016 suggested that insurance coverage for biologics used in the treatment of psoriasis was becoming increasingly difficult.¹⁴ Prior authorization requirement rates increased from 16% of patients in 2009 to 75% in 2014. The decision time also increased from 3.7 days in 2009 to 6.7 days in 2014. The most common reason for delay in decisions and denials was due to step therapy.¹⁴ Insurance companies wanted many patients to try less expensive treatment options prior to “stepping up” to more expensive treatments. Although this may be the case in the treatment of psoriasis, the role of step therapy is unclear for patients with AA because there is only 1 FDA-approved medication. This sets out an ambiguous future for our patients with AA and approval for baricitinib.

The time required for the correspondence between insurance companies, clinic staff, and patients for drug approval may delay treatments, and not all providers have enough staff to coordinate and perform this work. For Black patients, who may present more frequently and with more severe disease,⁷ this could lead to a health care disparity due to the likelihood of the increased need for biologic treatment. Because Black patients have an increased likelihood of being uninsured or underinsured,¹⁵ this further decreases the chances of the most severe AA patients receiving the most helpful medication for their condition.

Many pharmaceutical companies have drug cost assistance programs that aim to provide support covering expensive medications for patients unable to afford them. Although this is a good first step, treatment with any JAK inhibitor potentially can be lifelong. Regarding the social determinants of health, it is known that access to medications does not solely depend on cost. Transportation and access to qualified health professionals are among the issues that create barriers to health care. Instilling long-term practices to ensure equal access to JAK inhibitors and treatment of AA may be the cornerstone to treating AA with equity. Whether we require pharmaceutical companies to make sure all patients have equal access to medications or provide community resources to hairstylists and federally qualified health centers, raising awareness and advocating for and creating attainable access to treatment modalities is imperative to providing well-rounded care to a diverse population.

With the introduction of the first US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)–approved medication for alopecia areata (AA)—the Janus kinase (JAK) inhibitor, baricitinib—there is an important focus on this disease in the literature and for practicing dermatologists. Known by all as an autoimmune genetic disease that causes relapsing and remitting nonscarring hair loss, AA is a condition where the psychological burden has been less widely recognized. Patients with AA have reported lower health-related quality of life scores compared to patients with other skin conditions, including psoriasis or atopic dermatitis. In addition, a lesser amount of scalp coverage is negatively correlated to health-related quality of life scores.¹ Patients with AA also have a 39% lifetime prevalence of major depressive disorder and generalized anxiety disorder.² The treatment of AA has been a hodgepodge of topical, intralesional, and systemic agents, all with indirect immunosuppressive or anagen prolongation effects. Now that there is an approved therapy for AA with more treatments likely to be approved in the near future, there must be a focus on real-world outcomes. With the dawn of a new era in the treatment of AA as well as new information showcasing an altered prevalence of AA in skin of color, highlighting disparities among this population may help ease challenges dermatologic providers will face.

Efficacy of Baricitinib in Different Races and Ethnicities

How will patients of different races and ethnicities respond to this new treatment, and how will their emotional health be affected? The 2 phase 3 pivotal trials showing efficacy of baricitinib in AA included Black and Latino patients but not in a way that is representative of the US population.³ Until recently, the most commonly used prevalence of AA in the United States was from the NHANES I study completed between 1971 and 1974, which was between 0.1% and 0.2%⁴ with minimal focus on race and ethnicity. Recent studies suggest that there may be increased prevalence of this condition in Black patients in the United States. These new findings raise concern around access to care and treatment and the need to tailor psychosocial interventions for populations that may not currently have these supports.

A large cross-sectional study published in 2020 demonstrated that these data remained similar, with a lifetime prevalence of 0.21%.⁵ Of the 45,016 participants—representative of the US population based on the 2015 US Census—the average age of AA patients was 41.2 years, with 61.3% being White and not of Hispanic origin.⁵ In recent years, other studies have challenged the narrative that AA predominantly affects White patients.^6-8 A different cross-sectional study utilizing National Alopecia Areata Registry data from 2002 to 2016 suggested that Black patients have greater odds of developing AA.⁶ In this study of 2645 cases of AA, the odds ratios of developing the condition were 1.36 for Blacks, 0.53 for Asians, and 0.83 for Hispanics compared with the referent White population. These results were consistent through the varying subtypes of AA.⁶ In a reply to these findings, Gonzalez and Fleischer⁷ analyzed data from the 2007 to 2016 National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey database with a focus on racial and ethnic prevalence of AA. This study concluded that Latino and non-White individuals had an increased likelihood of clinician visits for AA compared with White individuals.⁷

More evidence of the Black predominance of AA was demonstrated in a study published in 2018. In this large-scale study, 63,960 women from the Nurses’ Health Study (NHS) and 88,368 women from the Nurses’ Health Study II (NHSII) were included to examine prevalence of disease among these US women.⁸ Analysis showed increased odds of AA based on self-reported race in Black and Hispanic women. Lifetime incidence of AA was greater in Black women, with 2.63 and 5.23 in NHS and NHSII, respectively. It was hypothesized that hairstyling practices in Black and Hispanic women may cause AA to be more noticeable,⁸ which may drive patients to seek medical evaluation.

Feaster and McMichael⁹ published information on the epidemiology of AA in a busy hair loss clinic. This retrospective single-institution study of 265 pediatric and adult Black patients with AA seen over a 5-year period showed that patients aged 18 to 34 years were most likely to present for care, which accounted for 35.8% of the study population, followed by patients aged 10 to 17 years, which accounted for 15.1%. This study also found that females were the larger segment of AA patients, with an increased distribution of disease in young patients. Most of these patients (68.2%) had patchy hair loss, and the ophiasis pattern was seen in 15.1%.⁹ Although the pathogenesis of AA is linked to autoimmunity,¹⁰ the leading cause for these epidemiologic findings of increased prevalence in Black patients is still uncertain.

Baricitinib for AA

In June 2022, the FDA announced the first biologic drug approved for the treatment of AA—baricitinib. Baricitinib is an oral, selective, reversible inhibitor of JAK1 and JAK2.³ The phase 3 trials for baricitinib—BRAVE-AA1 (N=654) and BRAVE-AA2 (N=546)—were conducted between March 2019 and May 2020. In these double-blind, parallel-group, randomized, placebo-controlled trials, 33% of the patient population receiving baricitinib accomplished 80% or more scalp coverage at 36 weeks. The Severity of Alopecia Tool (SALT) score also decreased to 20 or less in 36 weeks. The BRAVE-AA1 and BRAVE-AA2 trials consisted of a total of 1200 patients, with only 98 identifying as Black. Of these 98 patients, 33 were randomly selected to receive placebo.³ With studies now suggesting that Black individuals have greater odds of AA compared with White individuals⁶ and Black patients being more likely to seek medical care for AA,⁷ the BRAVE-AA1 and BRAVE-AA2 study population did not allow for significant comparative data for Black patients. These studies did not document Latino patient involvement.³ Future studies in AA must recruit a diversified group of study participants to better reflect the patients with an increased likelihood of presenting with AA.

Other Treatments on the Horizon

Baricitinib likely will remain alone in its class for only a short time. Phase 3 trials have been completed for ritlecitinib, brepocitinib, and deuruxolitinib for AA. Ritlecitinib, an irreversible inhibitor of JAK3 and the tyrosine kinase expressed in hepatocellular carcinoma (TEC) kinase family, has met all end points in a phase 2b/3 study.¹¹ Brepocitinib is an oral tyrosine kinase 2/JAK1 inhibitor,¹² and deuruxolitinib is an investigational JAK1/2 inhibitor for AA.¹³

Prior authorizations have been the initial step for many drugs in varying fields of medical practice. A study completed in 2016 suggested that insurance coverage for biologics used in the treatment of psoriasis was becoming increasingly difficult.¹⁴ Prior authorization requirement rates increased from 16% of patients in 2009 to 75% in 2014. The decision time also increased from 3.7 days in 2009 to 6.7 days in 2014. The most common reason for delay in decisions and denials was due to step therapy.¹⁴ Insurance companies wanted many patients to try less expensive treatment options prior to “stepping up” to more expensive treatments. Although this may be the case in the treatment of psoriasis, the role of step therapy is unclear for patients with AA because there is only 1 FDA-approved medication. This sets out an ambiguous future for our patients with AA and approval for baricitinib.

The time required for the correspondence between insurance companies, clinic staff, and patients for drug approval may delay treatments, and not all providers have enough staff to coordinate and perform this work. For Black patients, who may present more frequently and with more severe disease,⁷ this could lead to a health care disparity due to the likelihood of the increased need for biologic treatment. Because Black patients have an increased likelihood of being uninsured or underinsured,¹⁵ this further decreases the chances of the most severe AA patients receiving the most helpful medication for their condition.

Many pharmaceutical companies have drug cost assistance programs that aim to provide support covering expensive medications for patients unable to afford them. Although this is a good first step, treatment with any JAK inhibitor potentially can be lifelong. Regarding the social determinants of health, it is known that access to medications does not solely depend on cost. Transportation and access to qualified health professionals are among the issues that create barriers to health care. Instilling long-term practices to ensure equal access to JAK inhibitors and treatment of AA may be the cornerstone to treating AA with equity. Whether we require pharmaceutical companies to make sure all patients have equal access to medications or provide community resources to hairstylists and federally qualified health centers, raising awareness and advocating for and creating attainable access to treatment modalities is imperative to providing well-rounded care to a diverse population.

With the introduction of the first US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)–approved medication for alopecia areata (AA)—the Janus kinase (JAK) inhibitor, baricitinib—there is an important focus on this disease in the literature and for practicing dermatologists. Known by all as an autoimmune genetic disease that causes relapsing and remitting nonscarring hair loss, AA is a condition where the psychological burden has been less widely recognized. Patients with AA have reported lower health-related quality of life scores compared to patients with other skin conditions, including psoriasis or atopic dermatitis. In addition, a lesser amount of scalp coverage is negatively correlated to health-related quality of life scores.¹ Patients with AA also have a 39% lifetime prevalence of major depressive disorder and generalized anxiety disorder.² The treatment of AA has been a hodgepodge of topical, intralesional, and systemic agents, all with indirect immunosuppressive or anagen prolongation effects. Now that there is an approved therapy for AA with more treatments likely to be approved in the near future, there must be a focus on real-world outcomes. With the dawn of a new era in the treatment of AA as well as new information showcasing an altered prevalence of AA in skin of color, highlighting disparities among this population may help ease challenges dermatologic providers will face.

Efficacy of Baricitinib in Different Races and Ethnicities

How will patients of different races and ethnicities respond to this new treatment, and how will their emotional health be affected? The 2 phase 3 pivotal trials showing efficacy of baricitinib in AA included Black and Latino patients but not in a way that is representative of the US population.³ Until recently, the most commonly used prevalence of AA in the United States was from the NHANES I study completed between 1971 and 1974, which was between 0.1% and 0.2%⁴ with minimal focus on race and ethnicity. Recent studies suggest that there may be increased prevalence of this condition in Black patients in the United States. These new findings raise concern around access to care and treatment and the need to tailor psychosocial interventions for populations that may not currently have these supports.

A large cross-sectional study published in 2020 demonstrated that these data remained similar, with a lifetime prevalence of 0.21%.⁵ Of the 45,016 participants—representative of the US population based on the 2015 US Census—the average age of AA patients was 41.2 years, with 61.3% being White and not of Hispanic origin.⁵ In recent years, other studies have challenged the narrative that AA predominantly affects White patients.^6-8 A different cross-sectional study utilizing National Alopecia Areata Registry data from 2002 to 2016 suggested that Black patients have greater odds of developing AA.⁶ In this study of 2645 cases of AA, the odds ratios of developing the condition were 1.36 for Blacks, 0.53 for Asians, and 0.83 for Hispanics compared with the referent White population. These results were consistent through the varying subtypes of AA.⁶ In a reply to these findings, Gonzalez and Fleischer⁷ analyzed data from the 2007 to 2016 National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey database with a focus on racial and ethnic prevalence of AA. This study concluded that Latino and non-White individuals had an increased likelihood of clinician visits for AA compared with White individuals.⁷

More evidence of the Black predominance of AA was demonstrated in a study published in 2018. In this large-scale study, 63,960 women from the Nurses’ Health Study (NHS) and 88,368 women from the Nurses’ Health Study II (NHSII) were included to examine prevalence of disease among these US women.⁸ Analysis showed increased odds of AA based on self-reported race in Black and Hispanic women. Lifetime incidence of AA was greater in Black women, with 2.63 and 5.23 in NHS and NHSII, respectively. It was hypothesized that hairstyling practices in Black and Hispanic women may cause AA to be more noticeable,⁸ which may drive patients to seek medical evaluation.

Feaster and McMichael⁹ published information on the epidemiology of AA in a busy hair loss clinic. This retrospective single-institution study of 265 pediatric and adult Black patients with AA seen over a 5-year period showed that patients aged 18 to 34 years were most likely to present for care, which accounted for 35.8% of the study population, followed by patients aged 10 to 17 years, which accounted for 15.1%. This study also found that females were the larger segment of AA patients, with an increased distribution of disease in young patients. Most of these patients (68.2%) had patchy hair loss, and the ophiasis pattern was seen in 15.1%.⁹ Although the pathogenesis of AA is linked to autoimmunity,¹⁰ the leading cause for these epidemiologic findings of increased prevalence in Black patients is still uncertain.

Baricitinib for AA

In June 2022, the FDA announced the first biologic drug approved for the treatment of AA—baricitinib. Baricitinib is an oral, selective, reversible inhibitor of JAK1 and JAK2.³ The phase 3 trials for baricitinib—BRAVE-AA1 (N=654) and BRAVE-AA2 (N=546)—were conducted between March 2019 and May 2020. In these double-blind, parallel-group, randomized, placebo-controlled trials, 33% of the patient population receiving baricitinib accomplished 80% or more scalp coverage at 36 weeks. The Severity of Alopecia Tool (SALT) score also decreased to 20 or less in 36 weeks. The BRAVE-AA1 and BRAVE-AA2 trials consisted of a total of 1200 patients, with only 98 identifying as Black. Of these 98 patients, 33 were randomly selected to receive placebo.³ With studies now suggesting that Black individuals have greater odds of AA compared with White individuals⁶ and Black patients being more likely to seek medical care for AA,⁷ the BRAVE-AA1 and BRAVE-AA2 study population did not allow for significant comparative data for Black patients. These studies did not document Latino patient involvement.³ Future studies in AA must recruit a diversified group of study participants to better reflect the patients with an increased likelihood of presenting with AA.

Other Treatments on the Horizon

Baricitinib likely will remain alone in its class for only a short time. Phase 3 trials have been completed for ritlecitinib, brepocitinib, and deuruxolitinib for AA. Ritlecitinib, an irreversible inhibitor of JAK3 and the tyrosine kinase expressed in hepatocellular carcinoma (TEC) kinase family, has met all end points in a phase 2b/3 study.¹¹ Brepocitinib is an oral tyrosine kinase 2/JAK1 inhibitor,¹² and deuruxolitinib is an investigational JAK1/2 inhibitor for AA.¹³

Prior authorizations have been the initial step for many drugs in varying fields of medical practice. A study completed in 2016 suggested that insurance coverage for biologics used in the treatment of psoriasis was becoming increasingly difficult.¹⁴ Prior authorization requirement rates increased from 16% of patients in 2009 to 75% in 2014. The decision time also increased from 3.7 days in 2009 to 6.7 days in 2014. The most common reason for delay in decisions and denials was due to step therapy.¹⁴ Insurance companies wanted many patients to try less expensive treatment options prior to “stepping up” to more expensive treatments. Although this may be the case in the treatment of psoriasis, the role of step therapy is unclear for patients with AA because there is only 1 FDA-approved medication. This sets out an ambiguous future for our patients with AA and approval for baricitinib.

The time required for the correspondence between insurance companies, clinic staff, and patients for drug approval may delay treatments, and not all providers have enough staff to coordinate and perform this work. For Black patients, who may present more frequently and with more severe disease,⁷ this could lead to a health care disparity due to the likelihood of the increased need for biologic treatment. Because Black patients have an increased likelihood of being uninsured or underinsured,¹⁵ this further decreases the chances of the most severe AA patients receiving the most helpful medication for their condition.

Many pharmaceutical companies have drug cost assistance programs that aim to provide support covering expensive medications for patients unable to afford them. Although this is a good first step, treatment with any JAK inhibitor potentially can be lifelong. Regarding the social determinants of health, it is known that access to medications does not solely depend on cost. Transportation and access to qualified health professionals are among the issues that create barriers to health care. Instilling long-term practices to ensure equal access to JAK inhibitors and treatment of AA may be the cornerstone to treating AA with equity. Whether we require pharmaceutical companies to make sure all patients have equal access to medications or provide community resources to hairstylists and federally qualified health centers, raising awareness and advocating for and creating attainable access to treatment modalities is imperative to providing well-rounded care to a diverse population.

Airbags are lifesaving during motor vehicle accidents (MVAs), but their deployment has been associated with skin issues such as irritant dermatitis¹; lacerations²; abrasions³; and thermal, friction, and chemical burns.^4-6 Ocular issues such as alkaline chemical keratitis⁷ and ocular alkali injuries⁸ also have been described.

Airbag deployment is triggered by rapid deceleration and impact, which ignite a sodium azide cartridge, causing the woven nylon bag to inflate with hydrocarbon gases.⁸ This leads to release of sodium hydroxide, sodium bicarbonate, and metallic oxides in an aerosolized form. If a tear in the meshwork of the airbag occurs, exposure to an even larger amount of powder containing caustic alkali chemicals can occur.⁸

We describe a patient who developed a bullous reaction to airbag contents after he was involved in an MVA in which the airbag deployed.

Case Report

A 35-year-old man with a history of type 2 diabetes mellitus and chronic hepatitis B presented to the dermatology clinic for an evaluation of new-onset blisters. The rash occurred 1 day after the patient was involved in an MVA in which he was exposed to the airbag’s contents after it burst. He had been evaluated twice in the emergency department for the skin eruption before being referred to dermatology. He noted the lesions were pruritic and painful. Prior treatments included silver sulfadiazine cream 1% and clobetasol cream 0.05%, though he discontinued using the latter because of burning with application. Physical examination revealed tense vesicles and bullae on an erythematous base on the right lower flank, forearms, and legs, with the exception of the lower right leg where a cast had been from a prior injury (Figure 1).

Two punch biopsies of the left arm were performed and sent for hematoxylin and eosin staining and direct immunofluorescence to rule out bullous diseases, such as bullous pemphigoid, linear IgA, and bullous lupus. Hematoxylin and eosin staining revealed extensive spongiosis with blister formation and a dense perivascular infiltrate in the superficial and mid dermis composed of lymphocytes with numerous scattered eosinophils (Figures 2 and 3). Direct immunofluorescence studies were negative. Treatment with oral prednisone and oral antihistamines was initiated.

At 10-day follow-up, the patient had a few residual bullae; most lesions were demonstrating various stages of healing (Figure 4). The patient’s cast had been removed, and there were no lesions in this previously covered area. At 6-week follow-up he had continued healing of the bullae and erosions as well as postinflammatory hyperpigmentation (Figure 5).

Comment

With the advent of airbags for safety purposes, these potentially lifesaving devices also have been known to cause injury.⁹ In 1998, the most commonly reported airbag injuries were ocular injuries.¹⁰ Cutaneous manifestations of airbag injury are less well known.¹¹

Two cases of airbag deployment with skin blistering have been reported in the literature based on a PubMed search of articles indexed for MEDLINE using the terms airbag blistering or airbag bullae^12,13; however, the blistering was described in the context of a burn. One case of the effects of airbag deployment residue highlights a patient arriving to the emergency department with erythema and blisters on the hands within 48 hours of airbag deployment in an MVA, and the treatment was standard burn therapy.¹² Another case report described a patient with a second-degree burn with a 12-cm blister occurring on the radial side of the hand and distal forearm following an MVA and airbag deployment, which was treated conservatively.¹³ Cases of thermal burns, chemical burns, and irritant contact dermatitis after airbag deployment have been described in the literature.^{4-6,11,12,14,15} Our patient’s distal right lower leg was covered with a cast for osteomyelitis, and no blisters had developed in this area. It is likely that the transfer of airbag contents occurred during the process of unbuckling his seatbelt, which could explain the bullae that developed on the right flank. Per the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, individuals should quickly remove clothing and wash their body with large amounts of soap and water following exposure to sodium azide.¹⁶

In 1989, the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 208 (occupant crash protection) became effective, stating all cars must have vehicle crash protection.¹² Prior to 1993, it was reported that there had been no associated chemical injuries with airbag deployment. Subsequently, a 6-month retrospective study in 1993 showed that dermal injuries were found in connection with the presence of sodium hydroxide in automobile airbags.¹² By 2004, it was known that airbags could cause chemical and thermal burns in addition to traumatic injuries from deployment.¹ Since 2007, all motor vehicles have been required to have advanced airbags, which are engineered to sense the presence of passengers and determine if the airbag will deploy, and if so, how much to deploy to minimize airbag-related injury.³

The brand of car that our patient drove during the MVA is one with known airbag recalls due to safety defects; however, the year and actual model of the vehicle are not known, so specific information about the airbag in question is not available. It has been noted that some defective airbag inflators that were exposed to excess moisture during the manufacturing process could explode during deployment, causing shrapnel and airbag rupture, which has been linked to nearly 300 injuries worldwide.¹⁷

Conclusion

It is evident that the use of airbag devices reduces morbidity and mortality due to MVAs.⁹ It also had been reported that up to 96% of airbag-related injuries are relatively minor, which many would argue justifies their use.¹⁸ Furthermore, it has been reported that 99.8% of skin injuries following airbag deployment are minor.¹⁹ In the United States, it is mandated that every vehicle have functional airbags installed.⁸

This case highlights the potential for substantial airbag-induced skin reactions, specifically a bullous reaction, following airbag deployment. The persistent pruritus and lasting postinflammatory hyperpigmentation seen in this case were certainly worrisome for our patient. We also present this case to remind dermatology providers of possible treatment approaches to these skin reactions. Immediate cleansing of the affected areas of skin may help avoid such reactions.

Airbags are lifesaving during motor vehicle accidents (MVAs), but their deployment has been associated with skin issues such as irritant dermatitis¹; lacerations²; abrasions³; and thermal, friction, and chemical burns.^4-6 Ocular issues such as alkaline chemical keratitis⁷ and ocular alkali injuries⁸ also have been described.

Airbag deployment is triggered by rapid deceleration and impact, which ignite a sodium azide cartridge, causing the woven nylon bag to inflate with hydrocarbon gases.⁸ This leads to release of sodium hydroxide, sodium bicarbonate, and metallic oxides in an aerosolized form. If a tear in the meshwork of the airbag occurs, exposure to an even larger amount of powder containing caustic alkali chemicals can occur.⁸

We describe a patient who developed a bullous reaction to airbag contents after he was involved in an MVA in which the airbag deployed.

Case Report

A 35-year-old man with a history of type 2 diabetes mellitus and chronic hepatitis B presented to the dermatology clinic for an evaluation of new-onset blisters. The rash occurred 1 day after the patient was involved in an MVA in which he was exposed to the airbag’s contents after it burst. He had been evaluated twice in the emergency department for the skin eruption before being referred to dermatology. He noted the lesions were pruritic and painful. Prior treatments included silver sulfadiazine cream 1% and clobetasol cream 0.05%, though he discontinued using the latter because of burning with application. Physical examination revealed tense vesicles and bullae on an erythematous base on the right lower flank, forearms, and legs, with the exception of the lower right leg where a cast had been from a prior injury (Figure 1).

Two punch biopsies of the left arm were performed and sent for hematoxylin and eosin staining and direct immunofluorescence to rule out bullous diseases, such as bullous pemphigoid, linear IgA, and bullous lupus. Hematoxylin and eosin staining revealed extensive spongiosis with blister formation and a dense perivascular infiltrate in the superficial and mid dermis composed of lymphocytes with numerous scattered eosinophils (Figures 2 and 3). Direct immunofluorescence studies were negative. Treatment with oral prednisone and oral antihistamines was initiated.

At 10-day follow-up, the patient had a few residual bullae; most lesions were demonstrating various stages of healing (Figure 4). The patient’s cast had been removed, and there were no lesions in this previously covered area. At 6-week follow-up he had continued healing of the bullae and erosions as well as postinflammatory hyperpigmentation (Figure 5).

Comment

With the advent of airbags for safety purposes, these potentially lifesaving devices also have been known to cause injury.⁹ In 1998, the most commonly reported airbag injuries were ocular injuries.¹⁰ Cutaneous manifestations of airbag injury are less well known.¹¹

Two cases of airbag deployment with skin blistering have been reported in the literature based on a PubMed search of articles indexed for MEDLINE using the terms airbag blistering or airbag bullae^12,13; however, the blistering was described in the context of a burn. One case of the effects of airbag deployment residue highlights a patient arriving to the emergency department with erythema and blisters on the hands within 48 hours of airbag deployment in an MVA, and the treatment was standard burn therapy.¹² Another case report described a patient with a second-degree burn with a 12-cm blister occurring on the radial side of the hand and distal forearm following an MVA and airbag deployment, which was treated conservatively.¹³ Cases of thermal burns, chemical burns, and irritant contact dermatitis after airbag deployment have been described in the literature.^{4-6,11,12,14,15} Our patient’s distal right lower leg was covered with a cast for osteomyelitis, and no blisters had developed in this area. It is likely that the transfer of airbag contents occurred during the process of unbuckling his seatbelt, which could explain the bullae that developed on the right flank. Per the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, individuals should quickly remove clothing and wash their body with large amounts of soap and water following exposure to sodium azide.¹⁶

In 1989, the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 208 (occupant crash protection) became effective, stating all cars must have vehicle crash protection.¹² Prior to 1993, it was reported that there had been no associated chemical injuries with airbag deployment. Subsequently, a 6-month retrospective study in 1993 showed that dermal injuries were found in connection with the presence of sodium hydroxide in automobile airbags.¹² By 2004, it was known that airbags could cause chemical and thermal burns in addition to traumatic injuries from deployment.¹ Since 2007, all motor vehicles have been required to have advanced airbags, which are engineered to sense the presence of passengers and determine if the airbag will deploy, and if so, how much to deploy to minimize airbag-related injury.³

The brand of car that our patient drove during the MVA is one with known airbag recalls due to safety defects; however, the year and actual model of the vehicle are not known, so specific information about the airbag in question is not available. It has been noted that some defective airbag inflators that were exposed to excess moisture during the manufacturing process could explode during deployment, causing shrapnel and airbag rupture, which has been linked to nearly 300 injuries worldwide.¹⁷

Conclusion

It is evident that the use of airbag devices reduces morbidity and mortality due to MVAs.⁹ It also had been reported that up to 96% of airbag-related injuries are relatively minor, which many would argue justifies their use.¹⁸ Furthermore, it has been reported that 99.8% of skin injuries following airbag deployment are minor.¹⁹ In the United States, it is mandated that every vehicle have functional airbags installed.⁸

This case highlights the potential for substantial airbag-induced skin reactions, specifically a bullous reaction, following airbag deployment. The persistent pruritus and lasting postinflammatory hyperpigmentation seen in this case were certainly worrisome for our patient. We also present this case to remind dermatology providers of possible treatment approaches to these skin reactions. Immediate cleansing of the affected areas of skin may help avoid such reactions.

Airbags are lifesaving during motor vehicle accidents (MVAs), but their deployment has been associated with skin issues such as irritant dermatitis¹; lacerations²; abrasions³; and thermal, friction, and chemical burns.^4-6 Ocular issues such as alkaline chemical keratitis⁷ and ocular alkali injuries⁸ also have been described.

Airbag deployment is triggered by rapid deceleration and impact, which ignite a sodium azide cartridge, causing the woven nylon bag to inflate with hydrocarbon gases.⁸ This leads to release of sodium hydroxide, sodium bicarbonate, and metallic oxides in an aerosolized form. If a tear in the meshwork of the airbag occurs, exposure to an even larger amount of powder containing caustic alkali chemicals can occur.⁸

We describe a patient who developed a bullous reaction to airbag contents after he was involved in an MVA in which the airbag deployed.

Case Report

A 35-year-old man with a history of type 2 diabetes mellitus and chronic hepatitis B presented to the dermatology clinic for an evaluation of new-onset blisters. The rash occurred 1 day after the patient was involved in an MVA in which he was exposed to the airbag’s contents after it burst. He had been evaluated twice in the emergency department for the skin eruption before being referred to dermatology. He noted the lesions were pruritic and painful. Prior treatments included silver sulfadiazine cream 1% and clobetasol cream 0.05%, though he discontinued using the latter because of burning with application. Physical examination revealed tense vesicles and bullae on an erythematous base on the right lower flank, forearms, and legs, with the exception of the lower right leg where a cast had been from a prior injury (Figure 1).

Two punch biopsies of the left arm were performed and sent for hematoxylin and eosin staining and direct immunofluorescence to rule out bullous diseases, such as bullous pemphigoid, linear IgA, and bullous lupus. Hematoxylin and eosin staining revealed extensive spongiosis with blister formation and a dense perivascular infiltrate in the superficial and mid dermis composed of lymphocytes with numerous scattered eosinophils (Figures 2 and 3). Direct immunofluorescence studies were negative. Treatment with oral prednisone and oral antihistamines was initiated.

At 10-day follow-up, the patient had a few residual bullae; most lesions were demonstrating various stages of healing (Figure 4). The patient’s cast had been removed, and there were no lesions in this previously covered area. At 6-week follow-up he had continued healing of the bullae and erosions as well as postinflammatory hyperpigmentation (Figure 5).

Comment

With the advent of airbags for safety purposes, these potentially lifesaving devices also have been known to cause injury.⁹ In 1998, the most commonly reported airbag injuries were ocular injuries.¹⁰ Cutaneous manifestations of airbag injury are less well known.¹¹

Two cases of airbag deployment with skin blistering have been reported in the literature based on a PubMed search of articles indexed for MEDLINE using the terms airbag blistering or airbag bullae^12,13; however, the blistering was described in the context of a burn. One case of the effects of airbag deployment residue highlights a patient arriving to the emergency department with erythema and blisters on the hands within 48 hours of airbag deployment in an MVA, and the treatment was standard burn therapy.¹² Another case report described a patient with a second-degree burn with a 12-cm blister occurring on the radial side of the hand and distal forearm following an MVA and airbag deployment, which was treated conservatively.¹³ Cases of thermal burns, chemical burns, and irritant contact dermatitis after airbag deployment have been described in the literature.^{4-6,11,12,14,15} Our patient’s distal right lower leg was covered with a cast for osteomyelitis, and no blisters had developed in this area. It is likely that the transfer of airbag contents occurred during the process of unbuckling his seatbelt, which could explain the bullae that developed on the right flank. Per the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, individuals should quickly remove clothing and wash their body with large amounts of soap and water following exposure to sodium azide.¹⁶

In 1989, the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 208 (occupant crash protection) became effective, stating all cars must have vehicle crash protection.¹² Prior to 1993, it was reported that there had been no associated chemical injuries with airbag deployment. Subsequently, a 6-month retrospective study in 1993 showed that dermal injuries were found in connection with the presence of sodium hydroxide in automobile airbags.¹² By 2004, it was known that airbags could cause chemical and thermal burns in addition to traumatic injuries from deployment.¹ Since 2007, all motor vehicles have been required to have advanced airbags, which are engineered to sense the presence of passengers and determine if the airbag will deploy, and if so, how much to deploy to minimize airbag-related injury.³

The brand of car that our patient drove during the MVA is one with known airbag recalls due to safety defects; however, the year and actual model of the vehicle are not known, so specific information about the airbag in question is not available. It has been noted that some defective airbag inflators that were exposed to excess moisture during the manufacturing process could explode during deployment, causing shrapnel and airbag rupture, which has been linked to nearly 300 injuries worldwide.¹⁷

Conclusion

It is evident that the use of airbag devices reduces morbidity and mortality due to MVAs.⁹ It also had been reported that up to 96% of airbag-related injuries are relatively minor, which many would argue justifies their use.¹⁸ Furthermore, it has been reported that 99.8% of skin injuries following airbag deployment are minor.¹⁹ In the United States, it is mandated that every vehicle have functional airbags installed.⁸

This case highlights the potential for substantial airbag-induced skin reactions, specifically a bullous reaction, following airbag deployment. The persistent pruritus and lasting postinflammatory hyperpigmentation seen in this case were certainly worrisome for our patient. We also present this case to remind dermatology providers of possible treatment approaches to these skin reactions. Immediate cleansing of the affected areas of skin may help avoid such reactions.

Vitiligo is a chronic dermatologic condition that negatively affects quality of life (QOL), with substantial burden on the psychosocial well-being of patients.¹ There is no cure, and current treatment modalities are aimed at controlling the chronic relapsing condition.^1-3 Despite topical and cosmetic treatments for stabilization and repigmentation, vitiligo remains unpredictable.³

All genders, races, ethnicities, and socioeconomic classes are equally affected.⁴ The underlying etiology of vitiligo remains unknown to a great extent and is more poorly understood by the general public compared with other skin diseases (eg, acne).⁵ Patients with vitiligo experience social withdrawal, decreased sense of self-esteem, anxiety, depression, and suicidal ideation.^5,6 Stigmatization has the greatest impact on QOL, with strong correlations between avoidance behaviors and lesion concealment.^6-8 Although the condition is especially disfiguring for darker skin types, lighter skin types also are substantially affected, with similar overall self-reported stress.^6,7

Individuals with chronic illnesses such as vitiligo turn to online communities for health information and social support, commiserating with others who have the same condition.^9,10 Online forums are platforms for asynchronous peer-to-peer exchange of disease-related information for better management of long-term disease.¹¹ Moreover, of all available internet resources, online forum posts are the most commonly accessed source of information (91%) for patients following visits with their doctors.¹²

Qualitative research involving chronic skin conditions and the information exchanged in online forums has been conducted for patients with acne, psoriasis, and atopic dermatitis, but not for patients with vitiligo.^13-16 Although online questionnaires have been administered to patients with vitiligo, the content within online forums is not well characterized.^2,17

The purpose of this qualitative study was to evaluate the online content exchanged by individuals with vitiligo to better understand the general attitudes and help-seeking behaviors in online forums.

Methods

Study Design—This qualitative study sought to investigate health beliefs and messages about vitiligo posted by users in US-based online discussion forums. An interpretive research paradigm was utilized so that all content collected in online forums were the views expressed by individuals.^18-20 An integrated approach was used in the development of the coding manual, with pre-established major themes and subthemes as a guiding framework.^16,21,22 We adhered to an inductive grounded method by means of de novo line-by-line coding, such that we had flexibility for new subthemes to emerge throughout the duration of the entire coding process.²³

Individual posts and subsequent replies embedded within public online forums were used as the collected data source. Google was utilized as the primary search engine to identify forums pertaining to vitiligo, as 80% of US adults with chronic disease report that their inquiries for health information start with Google, Bing, or Yahoo.²⁴ The institutional review board at the Wake Forest School of Medicine (Winston-Salem, North Carolina) granted approval of the study (IRB00063073). Online forums were considered “property” of the public domain and were accessible to all, eliminating the need for written informed consent.^24-26

Search Criteria—We conducted our forum search in February 2020 with a systematic approach using predetermined phrases—online forum vitiligo support, vitiligo online message board, and vitiligo forums—which yielded more than 358,171 total results (eTable 1). Threads were identified in chronological order (from newest to oldest) based on how they appeared during each internet search, and all Google results for the respective search phrases were reviewed. Dates of selected threads ranged from 2005 to 2020. Only sites with US domains were included. Posts that either included views and understandings of vitiligo or belonged to a thread that contained a vitiligo discussion were deemed relevant for inclusion. Forums were excluded if registration or means of payment was required to view posts, if there were fewer than 2 user replies to a thread, if threads contained patient photographs, or if no posts had been made in the last 2 years (rendering the thread inactive). No social media platforms, such as Facebook, or formal online platforms, such as MyVitiligoTeam, were included in the search. A no-fee-for-access was chosen for this study, as the majority of those with a chronic condition who encounter a required paywall find the information elsewhere.²⁵

Data Analysis—A total of 39 online forums were deemed relevant to the topic of vitiligo; 9 of them met inclusion criteria (eTable 2). The messages within the forums were copied verbatim into a password-encrypted text document, and usernames in the threads were de-identified, ensuring user confidentiality.

An inductive thematic analysis was utilized to explore the views and beliefs of online forum users discussing vitiligo. One author (M.B.G.) read the extracted message threads, developed an initial codebook, and established a finalized version with the agreement of another author (A.M.B.)(eTable 3). The forums were independently coded (M.B.G. and A.M.B.) in a line-by-line manner according to the codebook. Discrepancies were documented and resolved. Data saturation was adequately achieved, such that no new themes emerged during the iterative coding process. NVivo was used for qualitative analysis.

Results

Nine forums met inclusion criteria, comprising 105 pages of text. There were 61 total discussion threads, with 382 anonymous contributing users. Most users initiated a thread by posting either a question, an advice statement, or a request for help. The psychosocial impact of the disease permeated multiple domains,including personal relationships and daily life. Several threads discussed treatment, including effective camouflage and makeup, as well as peer validation of physician-prescribed treatments, along with threads dedicated to “cures” or homeopathy regimens. In several instances, commercial product endorsement, testimonials, and marketing links were reposted by the same user multiple times.

Inductive thematic analysis highlighted diverse themes and subthemes related to the beliefs and perspectives of users with vitiligo or with relatives or friends with vitiligo: psychosocial impact, disease management and camouflage/concealment, alternative medicine/homeopathy/cures, interactions with the public and health care providers, and skin tone and race. Quotes from individuals were included to demonstrate themes and subthemes.

Psychosocial Impact: QOL, Sources of Support, and Coping—There was a broad range of comments on how patients cope with and view their vitiligo. Some individuals felt vitiligo made them special, and others were at peace with and accepted their condition. In contrast, others reported the disease had devastated them and interfered with relationships. Individuals shared their stories of grief and hardships through childhood and adulthood and their concerns, especially on affected visible areas or the potential for disease progression. Users were vocal about how vitiligo affected their daily routines and lives, sharing how they felt uncomfortable outside the home, no longer engaged in swimming or exposing their legs, and preferred to stay inside instead. Some users adopted a “tough love” approach to coping, sharing how they have learned to either embrace their vitiligo or “live with it.” Some examples include:

“My best advice is go with the flow, vitiligo is not the worst thing that can happen.”

“I hate my life with vitiligo yet really I feel so selfish that there is much worse suffering in the world than a few white patches.”

Other advice was very practical:

“I hope it isn’t vanity that is tearing you apart because that is only skin deep. Make a fashion statement with hats.”

Some users acknowledged and adopted the mantra that vitiligo is not a somatic condition or “physical ailment,” while others emphasized its pervasive psychological burden:

“I still deal with this psychologically . . . You must keep a positive attitude and frame of mind . . . Vitiligo will not kill you, but you do need to stay strong and keep your head up emotionally.”

“I am just really thankful that I have a disease that will not kill me or that has [not] affected me physically at all. I consider myself lucky.”

Disease Management: Treatment, Vitiligo Course, Advice-Seeking, Camouflage—The range of information discussed for treatment was highly variable. There were many accounts in which users advised others to seek professional help, namely that of a dermatologist, for a formal assessment. Many expressed frustrations with treatments and their ineffectiveness, to which the majority of users said to consult with a professional and to remain patient and hopeful/optimistic:

“The best thing to do would be to take an appointment with a dermatologist and have the discoloration checked out. That’s the only way to know whether it is vitiligo or not.”

“My way of dealing with it is to gain control by camouflage.”

“The calming effect of being in control of my vitiligo, whether with concealers, self-tan or anything else, has stopped my feelings of despair.”

Beliefs on Alternative Medicine: Homeopathy and Alternative Regimens—Although some threads started with a post asking for the best treatments, others initiated a discussion by posting “best herbal treatments for cure” or “how to cure my vitiligo,” emphasizing the beliefs and wishes for a cure for vitiligo. Alternative therapies that users endorsed included apple cider vinegar, toothpaste, vitamins, and Ayurvedic treatment, among others. Dietary plans were popular, with users claiming success with dietary alterations in stopping and preventing lesion progression. For example, individuals felt that avoidance of sugar, meat, dairy, and citrus fruits or drinks and consumption of only filtered water were crucial to preventing further lesion spread and resulted in their “cure”:

“Don’t eat chocolate, wine (made of grapes), coffee, or tea if you don’t want to have vitiligo or let it get worse. Take Vitamin B, biotin, and nuts for Vitamin E.”

Other dangerous messages pitted treatments by health professionals against beliefs in homeopathy:

“I feel that vitiligo treatment is all in your diet and vitamins. All that medicine and UV lights is a no-no . . .w ith every medicine there is a side effect. The doctors could be healing your vitiligo and severely damaging you inside and out, and you won’t know until years later.”

There was a minor presence of users advising against homeopathy and the associated misinformation and inaccurate claims on curing vitiligo, though this group was small in comparison to the number of users posting outlandish claims on cure:

“There is no cure . . . It’s where your immune system attacks your skin cells causing loss of pigmentation. The skin that has lost the pigmentation can’t be reversed.”

Interactions With the Public and Health Care Providers—Those with vitiligo encounter unique situations in public and in their daily lives. Many of the accounts shared anecdotal stories on how patients have handled the stigma and discrimination faced:

“I have had to face discrimination at school, public places, college, functions, and every new person I have met has asked me this: ‘how did this happen?’”

Those with vitiligo even stated how they wished others would deal with their condition out in public, hoping that others would directly ask what the lesions were instead of the more hurtful staring. There were many stories in which users said others feel vitiligo was contagious or “dirty” and stressed that the condition is not infectious:

“I refer to myself as ‘camo-man’ and reassure people I come into contact with that it is not contagious.”

“Once I was eating at a restaurant . . . and a little girl said to her mom, ‘Look, Mom, that lady doesn’t wash her arms, look how dirty they are.’ That just broke my heart.”

Skin Tone and Implications—The belief that vitiligo lesions are less dramatic or less anxiety provoking for individuals with lighter skin was noted by users themselves and by health care providers in certain cases. Skin tone and its impact on QOL was confusing and contentious. Some users with fair skin stated their vitiligo was “less of an annoyance” or “less obvious” compared with individuals with darker complexions. Conversely, other accounts of self-reported White users vehemently stressed the anxieties felt by depigmented lesions, despite being “already white at baseline.”

“Was told by my dermatologist (upon diagnosis) that ‘You’re lucky you’re not African American—it shows up on them much worse. You’re so fair, it doesn’t really matter.’ ”

“You didn’t say what race you are. I could imagine it has a bigger impact if you are anything other than White.”

Comment

Patients Looking for Cures—The general attitude within the forums was uplifting and encouraging, with users detailing how they respond to others in public and sharing their personal perspectives. We found a mix of information regarding disease management and treatment of vitiligo. Overall, there was uncertainty about treatments, with individuals expressing concern that their treatments were ineffective or had failed or that better alternatives would be more suitable for their condition. We found many anecdotal endorsements of homeopathic remedies for vitiligo, with users boasting that their disease had not only been cured but had never returned. Some users completely denounced these statements, while other threads seemed to revolve completely around “cure” discussions with no dissenting voices. The number of discussions related to homeopathy was concerning. Furthermore, there often were no moderators within threads to remove cure-related content, whether commercially endorsed or anecdotal. It is plausible that supplements and vitamins recommended by some physicians may be incorrectly interpreted as a “cure” in online discussions. Our findings are consistent with prior reports that forums are a platform to express dissatisfaction with treatment and the need for additional treatment options.^15,22

Concern Expressed by Health Care Providers—Prior qualitative research has described how patients with chronic dermatologic conditions believe that health care providers minimize patients’ psychological distress.^27,28 We found several accounts in which an individual had explicitly stated their provider had “belittled” the extent and impact of vitiligo when comparing skin phototypes. This suggests either that physicians underestimate the impact of vitiligo on their patients or that physicians are not expressing enough empathic concern about the impact the condition has on those affected.

Cosmetic Aspects of Vitiligo—Few clinical trials have investigated QOL and cosmetic acceptability of treatments as outcome measures.²⁹ We found several instances in which users with vitiligo had reported being dismissed as having a “cosmetic disease,” consistent with other work demonstrating the negative impact on such dismissals.²² Moreover, concealment and camouflage techniques frequently were discussed, demonstrating the relevance of cosmetic management as an important research topic.

Trustworthy Sources of Health Information—Patients still view physicians as trustworthy and a key source of health care information and advice.^30-32 Patients with vitiligo who have been directed to reliable information sources often express gratitude²² and want health professionals to remain an important source in their health information-seeking.³¹ Given the range in information discussed online, it may be valuable to invite patients to share what information they have encountered online.

Our study highlights the conflicting health information and advice shared by users in online forums, complicating an already psychologically burdensome condition. Guiding patients to credible, moderated sites and resources that are accurate, understandable, and easy to access may help dispel the conflicting messages and stories discussed in the online community.

Study Strengths and Limitations—Limitations included reporting bias and reliance on self-reported information on the diagnosis and extent of individuals’ vitiligo. Excluding social media websites and platforms from the data collection is a limitation to comprehensively assessing the topic of internet users with vitiligo. Many social media platforms direct patients and their family members to support groups and therefore may have excluded these particular individuals. Social media platforms were excluded from our research owing to the prerequisite of creating user accounts or registering as an online member. Our inclusion criteria were specific to forums that did not require registering or creating an account and were therefore freely accessible to all internet viewers. There is an inherent lack of context present in online forums, preventing data collection on individuals’ demographics and socioeconomic backgrounds. However, anonymity may have allowed individuals to express their thoughts more freely.

An integrated approach, along with our sampling method of online forums not requiring registration, allows for greater transferability and understanding of the health needs of the general public with vitiligo.

Conclusion

Individuals with vitiligo continue to seek peer psychosocial support for the physical and emotional management of their disease. Counseling those with vitiligo about cosmetic concealment options, homeopathy, and treatment scams remains paramount. Directing patients to evidence-based resources, along with providing structured sources of support, may help to improve the psychosocial burden and QOL experienced by patients with vitiligo. Connecting patients with local and national support groups moderated by physicians, such as the Global Vitiligo Foundation (https://globalvitiligofoundation.org/), may provide benefit to patients with vitiligo.

Vitiligo is a chronic dermatologic condition that negatively affects quality of life (QOL), with substantial burden on the psychosocial well-being of patients.¹ There is no cure, and current treatment modalities are aimed at controlling the chronic relapsing condition.^1-3 Despite topical and cosmetic treatments for stabilization and repigmentation, vitiligo remains unpredictable.³

All genders, races, ethnicities, and socioeconomic classes are equally affected.⁴ The underlying etiology of vitiligo remains unknown to a great extent and is more poorly understood by the general public compared with other skin diseases (eg, acne).⁵ Patients with vitiligo experience social withdrawal, decreased sense of self-esteem, anxiety, depression, and suicidal ideation.^5,6 Stigmatization has the greatest impact on QOL, with strong correlations between avoidance behaviors and lesion concealment.^6-8 Although the condition is especially disfiguring for darker skin types, lighter skin types also are substantially affected, with similar overall self-reported stress.^6,7

Individuals with chronic illnesses such as vitiligo turn to online communities for health information and social support, commiserating with others who have the same condition.^9,10 Online forums are platforms for asynchronous peer-to-peer exchange of disease-related information for better management of long-term disease.¹¹ Moreover, of all available internet resources, online forum posts are the most commonly accessed source of information (91%) for patients following visits with their doctors.¹²

Qualitative research involving chronic skin conditions and the information exchanged in online forums has been conducted for patients with acne, psoriasis, and atopic dermatitis, but not for patients with vitiligo.^13-16 Although online questionnaires have been administered to patients with vitiligo, the content within online forums is not well characterized.^2,17

The purpose of this qualitative study was to evaluate the online content exchanged by individuals with vitiligo to better understand the general attitudes and help-seeking behaviors in online forums.

Methods

Study Design—This qualitative study sought to investigate health beliefs and messages about vitiligo posted by users in US-based online discussion forums. An interpretive research paradigm was utilized so that all content collected in online forums were the views expressed by individuals.^18-20 An integrated approach was used in the development of the coding manual, with pre-established major themes and subthemes as a guiding framework.^16,21,22 We adhered to an inductive grounded method by means of de novo line-by-line coding, such that we had flexibility for new subthemes to emerge throughout the duration of the entire coding process.²³

Individual posts and subsequent replies embedded within public online forums were used as the collected data source. Google was utilized as the primary search engine to identify forums pertaining to vitiligo, as 80% of US adults with chronic disease report that their inquiries for health information start with Google, Bing, or Yahoo.²⁴ The institutional review board at the Wake Forest School of Medicine (Winston-Salem, North Carolina) granted approval of the study (IRB00063073). Online forums were considered “property” of the public domain and were accessible to all, eliminating the need for written informed consent.^24-26

Search Criteria—We conducted our forum search in February 2020 with a systematic approach using predetermined phrases—online forum vitiligo support, vitiligo online message board, and vitiligo forums—which yielded more than 358,171 total results (eTable 1). Threads were identified in chronological order (from newest to oldest) based on how they appeared during each internet search, and all Google results for the respective search phrases were reviewed. Dates of selected threads ranged from 2005 to 2020. Only sites with US domains were included. Posts that either included views and understandings of vitiligo or belonged to a thread that contained a vitiligo discussion were deemed relevant for inclusion. Forums were excluded if registration or means of payment was required to view posts, if there were fewer than 2 user replies to a thread, if threads contained patient photographs, or if no posts had been made in the last 2 years (rendering the thread inactive). No social media platforms, such as Facebook, or formal online platforms, such as MyVitiligoTeam, were included in the search. A no-fee-for-access was chosen for this study, as the majority of those with a chronic condition who encounter a required paywall find the information elsewhere.²⁵

Data Analysis—A total of 39 online forums were deemed relevant to the topic of vitiligo; 9 of them met inclusion criteria (eTable 2). The messages within the forums were copied verbatim into a password-encrypted text document, and usernames in the threads were de-identified, ensuring user confidentiality.

An inductive thematic analysis was utilized to explore the views and beliefs of online forum users discussing vitiligo. One author (M.B.G.) read the extracted message threads, developed an initial codebook, and established a finalized version with the agreement of another author (A.M.B.)(eTable 3). The forums were independently coded (M.B.G. and A.M.B.) in a line-by-line manner according to the codebook. Discrepancies were documented and resolved. Data saturation was adequately achieved, such that no new themes emerged during the iterative coding process. NVivo was used for qualitative analysis.

Results

Nine forums met inclusion criteria, comprising 105 pages of text. There were 61 total discussion threads, with 382 anonymous contributing users. Most users initiated a thread by posting either a question, an advice statement, or a request for help. The psychosocial impact of the disease permeated multiple domains,including personal relationships and daily life. Several threads discussed treatment, including effective camouflage and makeup, as well as peer validation of physician-prescribed treatments, along with threads dedicated to “cures” or homeopathy regimens. In several instances, commercial product endorsement, testimonials, and marketing links were reposted by the same user multiple times.

Inductive thematic analysis highlighted diverse themes and subthemes related to the beliefs and perspectives of users with vitiligo or with relatives or friends with vitiligo: psychosocial impact, disease management and camouflage/concealment, alternative medicine/homeopathy/cures, interactions with the public and health care providers, and skin tone and race. Quotes from individuals were included to demonstrate themes and subthemes.

Psychosocial Impact: QOL, Sources of Support, and Coping—There was a broad range of comments on how patients cope with and view their vitiligo. Some individuals felt vitiligo made them special, and others were at peace with and accepted their condition. In contrast, others reported the disease had devastated them and interfered with relationships. Individuals shared their stories of grief and hardships through childhood and adulthood and their concerns, especially on affected visible areas or the potential for disease progression. Users were vocal about how vitiligo affected their daily routines and lives, sharing how they felt uncomfortable outside the home, no longer engaged in swimming or exposing their legs, and preferred to stay inside instead. Some users adopted a “tough love” approach to coping, sharing how they have learned to either embrace their vitiligo or “live with it.” Some examples include:

“My best advice is go with the flow, vitiligo is not the worst thing that can happen.”

“I hate my life with vitiligo yet really I feel so selfish that there is much worse suffering in the world than a few white patches.”

Other advice was very practical:

“I hope it isn’t vanity that is tearing you apart because that is only skin deep. Make a fashion statement with hats.”

Some users acknowledged and adopted the mantra that vitiligo is not a somatic condition or “physical ailment,” while others emphasized its pervasive psychological burden:

“I still deal with this psychologically . . . You must keep a positive attitude and frame of mind . . . Vitiligo will not kill you, but you do need to stay strong and keep your head up emotionally.”

“I am just really thankful that I have a disease that will not kill me or that has [not] affected me physically at all. I consider myself lucky.”

Disease Management: Treatment, Vitiligo Course, Advice-Seeking, Camouflage—The range of information discussed for treatment was highly variable. There were many accounts in which users advised others to seek professional help, namely that of a dermatologist, for a formal assessment. Many expressed frustrations with treatments and their ineffectiveness, to which the majority of users said to consult with a professional and to remain patient and hopeful/optimistic:

“The best thing to do would be to take an appointment with a dermatologist and have the discoloration checked out. That’s the only way to know whether it is vitiligo or not.”

“My way of dealing with it is to gain control by camouflage.”

“The calming effect of being in control of my vitiligo, whether with concealers, self-tan or anything else, has stopped my feelings of despair.”

Beliefs on Alternative Medicine: Homeopathy and Alternative Regimens—Although some threads started with a post asking for the best treatments, others initiated a discussion by posting “best herbal treatments for cure” or “how to cure my vitiligo,” emphasizing the beliefs and wishes for a cure for vitiligo. Alternative therapies that users endorsed included apple cider vinegar, toothpaste, vitamins, and Ayurvedic treatment, among others. Dietary plans were popular, with users claiming success with dietary alterations in stopping and preventing lesion progression. For example, individuals felt that avoidance of sugar, meat, dairy, and citrus fruits or drinks and consumption of only filtered water were crucial to preventing further lesion spread and resulted in their “cure”:

“Don’t eat chocolate, wine (made of grapes), coffee, or tea if you don’t want to have vitiligo or let it get worse. Take Vitamin B, biotin, and nuts for Vitamin E.”

Other dangerous messages pitted treatments by health professionals against beliefs in homeopathy:

“I feel that vitiligo treatment is all in your diet and vitamins. All that medicine and UV lights is a no-no . . .w ith every medicine there is a side effect. The doctors could be healing your vitiligo and severely damaging you inside and out, and you won’t know until years later.”

There was a minor presence of users advising against homeopathy and the associated misinformation and inaccurate claims on curing vitiligo, though this group was small in comparison to the number of users posting outlandish claims on cure:

“There is no cure . . . It’s where your immune system attacks your skin cells causing loss of pigmentation. The skin that has lost the pigmentation can’t be reversed.”

Interactions With the Public and Health Care Providers—Those with vitiligo encounter unique situations in public and in their daily lives. Many of the accounts shared anecdotal stories on how patients have handled the stigma and discrimination faced:

“I have had to face discrimination at school, public places, college, functions, and every new person I have met has asked me this: ‘how did this happen?’”

Those with vitiligo even stated how they wished others would deal with their condition out in public, hoping that others would directly ask what the lesions were instead of the more hurtful staring. There were many stories in which users said others feel vitiligo was contagious or “dirty” and stressed that the condition is not infectious:

“I refer to myself as ‘camo-man’ and reassure people I come into contact with that it is not contagious.”

“Once I was eating at a restaurant . . . and a little girl said to her mom, ‘Look, Mom, that lady doesn’t wash her arms, look how dirty they are.’ That just broke my heart.”

Skin Tone and Implications—The belief that vitiligo lesions are less dramatic or less anxiety provoking for individuals with lighter skin was noted by users themselves and by health care providers in certain cases. Skin tone and its impact on QOL was confusing and contentious. Some users with fair skin stated their vitiligo was “less of an annoyance” or “less obvious” compared with individuals with darker complexions. Conversely, other accounts of self-reported White users vehemently stressed the anxieties felt by depigmented lesions, despite being “already white at baseline.”

“Was told by my dermatologist (upon diagnosis) that ‘You’re lucky you’re not African American—it shows up on them much worse. You’re so fair, it doesn’t really matter.’ ”

“You didn’t say what race you are. I could imagine it has a bigger impact if you are anything other than White.”

Comment

Patients Looking for Cures—The general attitude within the forums was uplifting and encouraging, with users detailing how they respond to others in public and sharing their personal perspectives. We found a mix of information regarding disease management and treatment of vitiligo. Overall, there was uncertainty about treatments, with individuals expressing concern that their treatments were ineffective or had failed or that better alternatives would be more suitable for their condition. We found many anecdotal endorsements of homeopathic remedies for vitiligo, with users boasting that their disease had not only been cured but had never returned. Some users completely denounced these statements, while other threads seemed to revolve completely around “cure” discussions with no dissenting voices. The number of discussions related to homeopathy was concerning. Furthermore, there often were no moderators within threads to remove cure-related content, whether commercially endorsed or anecdotal. It is plausible that supplements and vitamins recommended by some physicians may be incorrectly interpreted as a “cure” in online discussions. Our findings are consistent with prior reports that forums are a platform to express dissatisfaction with treatment and the need for additional treatment options.^15,22

Concern Expressed by Health Care Providers—Prior qualitative research has described how patients with chronic dermatologic conditions believe that health care providers minimize patients’ psychological distress.^27,28 We found several accounts in which an individual had explicitly stated their provider had “belittled” the extent and impact of vitiligo when comparing skin phototypes. This suggests either that physicians underestimate the impact of vitiligo on their patients or that physicians are not expressing enough empathic concern about the impact the condition has on those affected.

Cosmetic Aspects of Vitiligo—Few clinical trials have investigated QOL and cosmetic acceptability of treatments as outcome measures.²⁹ We found several instances in which users with vitiligo had reported being dismissed as having a “cosmetic disease,” consistent with other work demonstrating the negative impact on such dismissals.²² Moreover, concealment and camouflage techniques frequently were discussed, demonstrating the relevance of cosmetic management as an important research topic.

Trustworthy Sources of Health Information—Patients still view physicians as trustworthy and a key source of health care information and advice.^30-32 Patients with vitiligo who have been directed to reliable information sources often express gratitude²² and want health professionals to remain an important source in their health information-seeking.³¹ Given the range in information discussed online, it may be valuable to invite patients to share what information they have encountered online.

Our study highlights the conflicting health information and advice shared by users in online forums, complicating an already psychologically burdensome condition. Guiding patients to credible, moderated sites and resources that are accurate, understandable, and easy to access may help dispel the conflicting messages and stories discussed in the online community.

Study Strengths and Limitations—Limitations included reporting bias and reliance on self-reported information on the diagnosis and extent of individuals’ vitiligo. Excluding social media websites and platforms from the data collection is a limitation to comprehensively assessing the topic of internet users with vitiligo. Many social media platforms direct patients and their family members to support groups and therefore may have excluded these particular individuals. Social media platforms were excluded from our research owing to the prerequisite of creating user accounts or registering as an online member. Our inclusion criteria were specific to forums that did not require registering or creating an account and were therefore freely accessible to all internet viewers. There is an inherent lack of context present in online forums, preventing data collection on individuals’ demographics and socioeconomic backgrounds. However, anonymity may have allowed individuals to express their thoughts more freely.

An integrated approach, along with our sampling method of online forums not requiring registration, allows for greater transferability and understanding of the health needs of the general public with vitiligo.

Conclusion

Individuals with vitiligo continue to seek peer psychosocial support for the physical and emotional management of their disease. Counseling those with vitiligo about cosmetic concealment options, homeopathy, and treatment scams remains paramount. Directing patients to evidence-based resources, along with providing structured sources of support, may help to improve the psychosocial burden and QOL experienced by patients with vitiligo. Connecting patients with local and national support groups moderated by physicians, such as the Global Vitiligo Foundation (https://globalvitiligofoundation.org/), may provide benefit to patients with vitiligo.

Vitiligo is a chronic dermatologic condition that negatively affects quality of life (QOL), with substantial burden on the psychosocial well-being of patients.¹ There is no cure, and current treatment modalities are aimed at controlling the chronic relapsing condition.^1-3 Despite topical and cosmetic treatments for stabilization and repigmentation, vitiligo remains unpredictable.³

All genders, races, ethnicities, and socioeconomic classes are equally affected.⁴ The underlying etiology of vitiligo remains unknown to a great extent and is more poorly understood by the general public compared with other skin diseases (eg, acne).⁵ Patients with vitiligo experience social withdrawal, decreased sense of self-esteem, anxiety, depression, and suicidal ideation.^5,6 Stigmatization has the greatest impact on QOL, with strong correlations between avoidance behaviors and lesion concealment.^6-8 Although the condition is especially disfiguring for darker skin types, lighter skin types also are substantially affected, with similar overall self-reported stress.^6,7

Individuals with chronic illnesses such as vitiligo turn to online communities for health information and social support, commiserating with others who have the same condition.^9,10 Online forums are platforms for asynchronous peer-to-peer exchange of disease-related information for better management of long-term disease.¹¹ Moreover, of all available internet resources, online forum posts are the most commonly accessed source of information (91%) for patients following visits with their doctors.¹²

Qualitative research involving chronic skin conditions and the information exchanged in online forums has been conducted for patients with acne, psoriasis, and atopic dermatitis, but not for patients with vitiligo.^13-16 Although online questionnaires have been administered to patients with vitiligo, the content within online forums is not well characterized.^2,17

The purpose of this qualitative study was to evaluate the online content exchanged by individuals with vitiligo to better understand the general attitudes and help-seeking behaviors in online forums.

Methods

Study Design—This qualitative study sought to investigate health beliefs and messages about vitiligo posted by users in US-based online discussion forums. An interpretive research paradigm was utilized so that all content collected in online forums were the views expressed by individuals.^18-20 An integrated approach was used in the development of the coding manual, with pre-established major themes and subthemes as a guiding framework.^16,21,22 We adhered to an inductive grounded method by means of de novo line-by-line coding, such that we had flexibility for new subthemes to emerge throughout the duration of the entire coding process.²³

Individual posts and subsequent replies embedded within public online forums were used as the collected data source. Google was utilized as the primary search engine to identify forums pertaining to vitiligo, as 80% of US adults with chronic disease report that their inquiries for health information start with Google, Bing, or Yahoo.²⁴ The institutional review board at the Wake Forest School of Medicine (Winston-Salem, North Carolina) granted approval of the study (IRB00063073). Online forums were considered “property” of the public domain and were accessible to all, eliminating the need for written informed consent.^24-26

Search Criteria—We conducted our forum search in February 2020 with a systematic approach using predetermined phrases—online forum vitiligo support, vitiligo online message board, and vitiligo forums—which yielded more than 358,171 total results (eTable 1). Threads were identified in chronological order (from newest to oldest) based on how they appeared during each internet search, and all Google results for the respective search phrases were reviewed. Dates of selected threads ranged from 2005 to 2020. Only sites with US domains were included. Posts that either included views and understandings of vitiligo or belonged to a thread that contained a vitiligo discussion were deemed relevant for inclusion. Forums were excluded if registration or means of payment was required to view posts, if there were fewer than 2 user replies to a thread, if threads contained patient photographs, or if no posts had been made in the last 2 years (rendering the thread inactive). No social media platforms, such as Facebook, or formal online platforms, such as MyVitiligoTeam, were included in the search. A no-fee-for-access was chosen for this study, as the majority of those with a chronic condition who encounter a required paywall find the information elsewhere.²⁵

Data Analysis—A total of 39 online forums were deemed relevant to the topic of vitiligo; 9 of them met inclusion criteria (eTable 2). The messages within the forums were copied verbatim into a password-encrypted text document, and usernames in the threads were de-identified, ensuring user confidentiality.

An inductive thematic analysis was utilized to explore the views and beliefs of online forum users discussing vitiligo. One author (M.B.G.) read the extracted message threads, developed an initial codebook, and established a finalized version with the agreement of another author (A.M.B.)(eTable 3). The forums were independently coded (M.B.G. and A.M.B.) in a line-by-line manner according to the codebook. Discrepancies were documented and resolved. Data saturation was adequately achieved, such that no new themes emerged during the iterative coding process. NVivo was used for qualitative analysis.

Results

Nine forums met inclusion criteria, comprising 105 pages of text. There were 61 total discussion threads, with 382 anonymous contributing users. Most users initiated a thread by posting either a question, an advice statement, or a request for help. The psychosocial impact of the disease permeated multiple domains,including personal relationships and daily life. Several threads discussed treatment, including effective camouflage and makeup, as well as peer validation of physician-prescribed treatments, along with threads dedicated to “cures” or homeopathy regimens. In several instances, commercial product endorsement, testimonials, and marketing links were reposted by the same user multiple times.

Inductive thematic analysis highlighted diverse themes and subthemes related to the beliefs and perspectives of users with vitiligo or with relatives or friends with vitiligo: psychosocial impact, disease management and camouflage/concealment, alternative medicine/homeopathy/cures, interactions with the public and health care providers, and skin tone and race. Quotes from individuals were included to demonstrate themes and subthemes.

Psychosocial Impact: QOL, Sources of Support, and Coping—There was a broad range of comments on how patients cope with and view their vitiligo. Some individuals felt vitiligo made them special, and others were at peace with and accepted their condition. In contrast, others reported the disease had devastated them and interfered with relationships. Individuals shared their stories of grief and hardships through childhood and adulthood and their concerns, especially on affected visible areas or the potential for disease progression. Users were vocal about how vitiligo affected their daily routines and lives, sharing how they felt uncomfortable outside the home, no longer engaged in swimming or exposing their legs, and preferred to stay inside instead. Some users adopted a “tough love” approach to coping, sharing how they have learned to either embrace their vitiligo or “live with it.” Some examples include:

“My best advice is go with the flow, vitiligo is not the worst thing that can happen.”

“I hate my life with vitiligo yet really I feel so selfish that there is much worse suffering in the world than a few white patches.”

Other advice was very practical:

“I hope it isn’t vanity that is tearing you apart because that is only skin deep. Make a fashion statement with hats.”

Some users acknowledged and adopted the mantra that vitiligo is not a somatic condition or “physical ailment,” while others emphasized its pervasive psychological burden:

“I still deal with this psychologically . . . You must keep a positive attitude and frame of mind . . . Vitiligo will not kill you, but you do need to stay strong and keep your head up emotionally.”

“I am just really thankful that I have a disease that will not kill me or that has [not] affected me physically at all. I consider myself lucky.”

Disease Management: Treatment, Vitiligo Course, Advice-Seeking, Camouflage—The range of information discussed for treatment was highly variable. There were many accounts in which users advised others to seek professional help, namely that of a dermatologist, for a formal assessment. Many expressed frustrations with treatments and their ineffectiveness, to which the majority of users said to consult with a professional and to remain patient and hopeful/optimistic:

“The best thing to do would be to take an appointment with a dermatologist and have the discoloration checked out. That’s the only way to know whether it is vitiligo or not.”

“My way of dealing with it is to gain control by camouflage.”

“The calming effect of being in control of my vitiligo, whether with concealers, self-tan or anything else, has stopped my feelings of despair.”

Beliefs on Alternative Medicine: Homeopathy and Alternative Regimens—Although some threads started with a post asking for the best treatments, others initiated a discussion by posting “best herbal treatments for cure” or “how to cure my vitiligo,” emphasizing the beliefs and wishes for a cure for vitiligo. Alternative therapies that users endorsed included apple cider vinegar, toothpaste, vitamins, and Ayurvedic treatment, among others. Dietary plans were popular, with users claiming success with dietary alterations in stopping and preventing lesion progression. For example, individuals felt that avoidance of sugar, meat, dairy, and citrus fruits or drinks and consumption of only filtered water were crucial to preventing further lesion spread and resulted in their “cure”:

“Don’t eat chocolate, wine (made of grapes), coffee, or tea if you don’t want to have vitiligo or let it get worse. Take Vitamin B, biotin, and nuts for Vitamin E.”

Other dangerous messages pitted treatments by health professionals against beliefs in homeopathy:

“I feel that vitiligo treatment is all in your diet and vitamins. All that medicine and UV lights is a no-no . . .w ith every medicine there is a side effect. The doctors could be healing your vitiligo and severely damaging you inside and out, and you won’t know until years later.”

There was a minor presence of users advising against homeopathy and the associated misinformation and inaccurate claims on curing vitiligo, though this group was small in comparison to the number of users posting outlandish claims on cure:

“There is no cure . . . It’s where your immune system attacks your skin cells causing loss of pigmentation. The skin that has lost the pigmentation can’t be reversed.”

Interactions With the Public and Health Care Providers—Those with vitiligo encounter unique situations in public and in their daily lives. Many of the accounts shared anecdotal stories on how patients have handled the stigma and discrimination faced:

“I have had to face discrimination at school, public places, college, functions, and every new person I have met has asked me this: ‘how did this happen?’”

Those with vitiligo even stated how they wished others would deal with their condition out in public, hoping that others would directly ask what the lesions were instead of the more hurtful staring. There were many stories in which users said others feel vitiligo was contagious or “dirty” and stressed that the condition is not infectious:

“I refer to myself as ‘camo-man’ and reassure people I come into contact with that it is not contagious.”

“Once I was eating at a restaurant . . . and a little girl said to her mom, ‘Look, Mom, that lady doesn’t wash her arms, look how dirty they are.’ That just broke my heart.”

Skin Tone and Implications—The belief that vitiligo lesions are less dramatic or less anxiety provoking for individuals with lighter skin was noted by users themselves and by health care providers in certain cases. Skin tone and its impact on QOL was confusing and contentious. Some users with fair skin stated their vitiligo was “less of an annoyance” or “less obvious” compared with individuals with darker complexions. Conversely, other accounts of self-reported White users vehemently stressed the anxieties felt by depigmented lesions, despite being “already white at baseline.”

“Was told by my dermatologist (upon diagnosis) that ‘You’re lucky you’re not African American—it shows up on them much worse. You’re so fair, it doesn’t really matter.’ ”

“You didn’t say what race you are. I could imagine it has a bigger impact if you are anything other than White.”

Comment

Patients Looking for Cures—The general attitude within the forums was uplifting and encouraging, with users detailing how they respond to others in public and sharing their personal perspectives. We found a mix of information regarding disease management and treatment of vitiligo. Overall, there was uncertainty about treatments, with individuals expressing concern that their treatments were ineffective or had failed or that better alternatives would be more suitable for their condition. We found many anecdotal endorsements of homeopathic remedies for vitiligo, with users boasting that their disease had not only been cured but had never returned. Some users completely denounced these statements, while other threads seemed to revolve completely around “cure” discussions with no dissenting voices. The number of discussions related to homeopathy was concerning. Furthermore, there often were no moderators within threads to remove cure-related content, whether commercially endorsed or anecdotal. It is plausible that supplements and vitamins recommended by some physicians may be incorrectly interpreted as a “cure” in online discussions. Our findings are consistent with prior reports that forums are a platform to express dissatisfaction with treatment and the need for additional treatment options.^15,22

Concern Expressed by Health Care Providers—Prior qualitative research has described how patients with chronic dermatologic conditions believe that health care providers minimize patients’ psychological distress.^27,28 We found several accounts in which an individual had explicitly stated their provider had “belittled” the extent and impact of vitiligo when comparing skin phototypes. This suggests either that physicians underestimate the impact of vitiligo on their patients or that physicians are not expressing enough empathic concern about the impact the condition has on those affected.

Cosmetic Aspects of Vitiligo—Few clinical trials have investigated QOL and cosmetic acceptability of treatments as outcome measures.²⁹ We found several instances in which users with vitiligo had reported being dismissed as having a “cosmetic disease,” consistent with other work demonstrating the negative impact on such dismissals.²² Moreover, concealment and camouflage techniques frequently were discussed, demonstrating the relevance of cosmetic management as an important research topic.

Trustworthy Sources of Health Information—Patients still view physicians as trustworthy and a key source of health care information and advice.^30-32 Patients with vitiligo who have been directed to reliable information sources often express gratitude²² and want health professionals to remain an important source in their health information-seeking.³¹ Given the range in information discussed online, it may be valuable to invite patients to share what information they have encountered online.

Our study highlights the conflicting health information and advice shared by users in online forums, complicating an already psychologically burdensome condition. Guiding patients to credible, moderated sites and resources that are accurate, understandable, and easy to access may help dispel the conflicting messages and stories discussed in the online community.

Study Strengths and Limitations—Limitations included reporting bias and reliance on self-reported information on the diagnosis and extent of individuals’ vitiligo. Excluding social media websites and platforms from the data collection is a limitation to comprehensively assessing the topic of internet users with vitiligo. Many social media platforms direct patients and their family members to support groups and therefore may have excluded these particular individuals. Social media platforms were excluded from our research owing to the prerequisite of creating user accounts or registering as an online member. Our inclusion criteria were specific to forums that did not require registering or creating an account and were therefore freely accessible to all internet viewers. There is an inherent lack of context present in online forums, preventing data collection on individuals’ demographics and socioeconomic backgrounds. However, anonymity may have allowed individuals to express their thoughts more freely.

An integrated approach, along with our sampling method of online forums not requiring registration, allows for greater transferability and understanding of the health needs of the general public with vitiligo.

Conclusion

Individuals with vitiligo continue to seek peer psychosocial support for the physical and emotional management of their disease. Counseling those with vitiligo about cosmetic concealment options, homeopathy, and treatment scams remains paramount. Directing patients to evidence-based resources, along with providing structured sources of support, may help to improve the psychosocial burden and QOL experienced by patients with vitiligo. Connecting patients with local and national support groups moderated by physicians, such as the Global Vitiligo Foundation (https://globalvitiligofoundation.org/), may provide benefit to patients with vitiligo.

As manifestations of overt racism and macroaggressions have gained increased visibility, there is a need for discussion of another expression of racism: microaggressions. Although racism classically is viewed as blatant structural, attitudinal, and behavioral prejudice, experts pose that the face of racism has evolved into a more covert insidious form. This form of racism was originally coined racial microaggressions by psychiatrist Chester M. Pierce, MD, 50 years ago.^1,2 Since that time, microaggressions have further expanded to describe “brief and commonplace daily verbal, behavioral, and environmental indignities, whether intentional or unintentional, that communicate hostile, derogatory, or negative racial, gender, sexual-orientation, and religious slights and insults to the target person or group.” ³ This article aims to define and depict examples of microaggressions in medicine, discuss the resulting harmful effects, and offer strategies to minimize and counter these negative ramifications.

What are microaggressions?

Microaggressions are behaviors that stem from implicit bias and occur at an interpersonal level. Implicit bias refers to unconscious stereotypes, assumptions, and beliefs held about an individual’s identity. One of the earliest microaggressions—invisibility—was characterized by Ralph Ellison in his novel Invisible Man. Ellison states, “I am invisible, understand, simply because people refuse to see me . . . When they approach me they see only my surroundings, themselves, or figments of their imagination—indeed, everything and anything except me.”⁴ This concept of invisibility is a primary microaggression faced by people of color.

In medicine, microaggressions and implicit bias may be encountered throughout medical training and clinical practice in interactions with colleagues, superiors, patients, and patients’ families.^5,6 Examples of microaggressions in medicine include demeaning comments, nonverbal disrespect, generalizations of social identity, assumption of nonphysician status, role- or credential-questioning behavior, explicit epithets, rejection of care, questioning or inquiries of ethnic/racial origin, and sexual harassment.⁷

An example of microaggressions in medicine was fully displayed when physician Tamika Cross described her experience of being turned away from helping an unresponsive passenger during a flight emergency.

[T]he flight attendant yells “call overhead for a physician on board.” I raised my hand to grab her attention. She said to me “oh no sweetie put [your] hand down, we are looking for actual physicians or nurses or some type of medical personnel, we don’t have time to talk to you” . . . Another “seasoned” white male approaches the row and says he is a physician as well. She says to me “thanks for your help but he can help us, and he has his credentials.”⁸

What are the effects of microaggressions?

Although microaggressions may be unconscious and unintentional by the offender, the negative ramifications are notable. Recent studies report that women and underrepresented minority (URM) medical students, residents, and physicians experience microaggressions and implicit bias at a higher prevalence and frequency compared with their male and non-URM counterparts.^7,9 Repetitive microaggressions are harmful to the health and safety of women and URM medical students, residents, physicians, other providers, and patients. The Table provides example scenarios of microaggressions in medicine categorized according to Berk.¹⁰

Microaggressions negatively impact physical, mental, and emotional well-being. Current data support that medical students and residents who experience microaggressions are more likely to report associated symptoms of burnout, depression, and suicidal thoughts.^11,12 Subjection to persistent bias can lead to minority status stress and racial battle fatigue, creating feelings of invisibility, isolation, exclusion, and loneliness for those impacted.^13,14

In the book Black Man in a White Coat: A Doctor’s Reflections on Race and Medicine, Damon Tweedy, MD, reflects on race in medicine. Tweedy notes his experience as a medical student when a professor mistakenly assumed he was a maintenance worker in the classroom. Tweedy describes how he internalized the exchange and, despite his success throughout the course of his medical training, combatted feelings of anxiety, self-doubt, and implied inferiority.¹⁵

Although microaggressions are harmful to one’s health, they also undermine the learning and teaching experience for students, residents, and faculty, and they detract from the larger goal of providing care for patients.¹¹ Frequent devaluing and questioning of an individual’s contributions, qualifications, and credentials based on identity can lower productivity and problem-solving abilities. These behaviors cultivate an unwelcome and hostile work/learning environment that is stressful and polarizing for the recipient.

Despite the heavy burden of microaggressions, most students, residents, and faculty physicians do not report incidents to their institutions and feel that training, resources, and policies to respond to bias adequately are lacking.⁷ As a result of implicit bias and microaggressions, women and URM medical students and providers are unable to focus solely on the practice of medicine. They are tasked with the additional burden of shouldering the emotional and cognitive complexities that microaggressions produce.¹⁶

What are strategies to reduce microaggressions in medicine?

To minimize the harmful effects of microaggressions, intervention strategies must be implemented that reduce the likelihood of the occurrence of microaggressions and challenge the stereotypes that undergird implicit bias. These strategies include cultivating allies, followed by demanding structural accountability. Allies are members of the majority group who collectively collaborate with members of the nonmajority group to effect change through the promotion of diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts.¹⁷ Cultivating allies involves building a network of collaboration among these groups and emphasizes education. Education is critical for allies to address microaggressions at the interpersonal level. This process of education involves personal reflection and self-awareness in exploring one’s biases, fears, and assumptions. Integral to this step is broadening one’s acceptance of different cultures, racial/ethnic groups, and identities. There must be a willingness to engage in difficult or uncomfortable conversations and a readiness to actively listen to concerns rather than perpetuating further harm through avoidance and dismissive or defensive behavior.¹⁸

Demanding structural accountability facilitates deconstruction of bias and microaggression at the larger systemic level. This strategy involves implicit bias and antiracism training, development of retention plans, and identification of mentors for women and URM providers and students. Implicit bias and microaggression training and policies should be incorporated into medical education and resident curriculums. Similarly, educational resources and training must be made available to practicing physicians, faculty, and other providers through their institutions and places of employment. Equipping students and providers with the tools needed when microaggressions are witnessed or experienced demonstrates systemic-level accountability and communicates the importance of the issue. Furthermore, the development of retention plans and identification of mentors provide a support system and foster a culture of inclusion where recipients of microaggressions feel protected and valued. Increased feelings of inclusivity and belonging help bridge the gap created through microaggressions and implicit bias.

Final Thoughts

Despite an often covert nature, the detrimental effects of microaggressions are tangible and far reaching. As providers, we must strive to understand all categories of racism and expose the many ways prejudice manifests within medical training and clinical practice. It is our obligation to undertake the challenge of “making the ‘invisible’ visible” as we confront microaggressions and implicit bias to promote a safer and more inclusive medical community and workforce.¹⁹

As manifestations of overt racism and macroaggressions have gained increased visibility, there is a need for discussion of another expression of racism: microaggressions. Although racism classically is viewed as blatant structural, attitudinal, and behavioral prejudice, experts pose that the face of racism has evolved into a more covert insidious form. This form of racism was originally coined racial microaggressions by psychiatrist Chester M. Pierce, MD, 50 years ago.^1,2 Since that time, microaggressions have further expanded to describe “brief and commonplace daily verbal, behavioral, and environmental indignities, whether intentional or unintentional, that communicate hostile, derogatory, or negative racial, gender, sexual-orientation, and religious slights and insults to the target person or group.” ³ This article aims to define and depict examples of microaggressions in medicine, discuss the resulting harmful effects, and offer strategies to minimize and counter these negative ramifications.

What are microaggressions?

Microaggressions are behaviors that stem from implicit bias and occur at an interpersonal level. Implicit bias refers to unconscious stereotypes, assumptions, and beliefs held about an individual’s identity. One of the earliest microaggressions—invisibility—was characterized by Ralph Ellison in his novel Invisible Man. Ellison states, “I am invisible, understand, simply because people refuse to see me . . . When they approach me they see only my surroundings, themselves, or figments of their imagination—indeed, everything and anything except me.”⁴ This concept of invisibility is a primary microaggression faced by people of color.

In medicine, microaggressions and implicit bias may be encountered throughout medical training and clinical practice in interactions with colleagues, superiors, patients, and patients’ families.^5,6 Examples of microaggressions in medicine include demeaning comments, nonverbal disrespect, generalizations of social identity, assumption of nonphysician status, role- or credential-questioning behavior, explicit epithets, rejection of care, questioning or inquiries of ethnic/racial origin, and sexual harassment.⁷

An example of microaggressions in medicine was fully displayed when physician Tamika Cross described her experience of being turned away from helping an unresponsive passenger during a flight emergency.

[T]he flight attendant yells “call overhead for a physician on board.” I raised my hand to grab her attention. She said to me “oh no sweetie put [your] hand down, we are looking for actual physicians or nurses or some type of medical personnel, we don’t have time to talk to you” . . . Another “seasoned” white male approaches the row and says he is a physician as well. She says to me “thanks for your help but he can help us, and he has his credentials.”⁸

What are the effects of microaggressions?

Although microaggressions may be unconscious and unintentional by the offender, the negative ramifications are notable. Recent studies report that women and underrepresented minority (URM) medical students, residents, and physicians experience microaggressions and implicit bias at a higher prevalence and frequency compared with their male and non-URM counterparts.^7,9 Repetitive microaggressions are harmful to the health and safety of women and URM medical students, residents, physicians, other providers, and patients. The Table provides example scenarios of microaggressions in medicine categorized according to Berk.¹⁰

Microaggressions negatively impact physical, mental, and emotional well-being. Current data support that medical students and residents who experience microaggressions are more likely to report associated symptoms of burnout, depression, and suicidal thoughts.^11,12 Subjection to persistent bias can lead to minority status stress and racial battle fatigue, creating feelings of invisibility, isolation, exclusion, and loneliness for those impacted.^13,14

In the book Black Man in a White Coat: A Doctor’s Reflections on Race and Medicine, Damon Tweedy, MD, reflects on race in medicine. Tweedy notes his experience as a medical student when a professor mistakenly assumed he was a maintenance worker in the classroom. Tweedy describes how he internalized the exchange and, despite his success throughout the course of his medical training, combatted feelings of anxiety, self-doubt, and implied inferiority.¹⁵

Although microaggressions are harmful to one’s health, they also undermine the learning and teaching experience for students, residents, and faculty, and they detract from the larger goal of providing care for patients.¹¹ Frequent devaluing and questioning of an individual’s contributions, qualifications, and credentials based on identity can lower productivity and problem-solving abilities. These behaviors cultivate an unwelcome and hostile work/learning environment that is stressful and polarizing for the recipient.

Despite the heavy burden of microaggressions, most students, residents, and faculty physicians do not report incidents to their institutions and feel that training, resources, and policies to respond to bias adequately are lacking.⁷ As a result of implicit bias and microaggressions, women and URM medical students and providers are unable to focus solely on the practice of medicine. They are tasked with the additional burden of shouldering the emotional and cognitive complexities that microaggressions produce.¹⁶

What are strategies to reduce microaggressions in medicine?

To minimize the harmful effects of microaggressions, intervention strategies must be implemented that reduce the likelihood of the occurrence of microaggressions and challenge the stereotypes that undergird implicit bias. These strategies include cultivating allies, followed by demanding structural accountability. Allies are members of the majority group who collectively collaborate with members of the nonmajority group to effect change through the promotion of diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts.¹⁷ Cultivating allies involves building a network of collaboration among these groups and emphasizes education. Education is critical for allies to address microaggressions at the interpersonal level. This process of education involves personal reflection and self-awareness in exploring one’s biases, fears, and assumptions. Integral to this step is broadening one’s acceptance of different cultures, racial/ethnic groups, and identities. There must be a willingness to engage in difficult or uncomfortable conversations and a readiness to actively listen to concerns rather than perpetuating further harm through avoidance and dismissive or defensive behavior.¹⁸

Demanding structural accountability facilitates deconstruction of bias and microaggression at the larger systemic level. This strategy involves implicit bias and antiracism training, development of retention plans, and identification of mentors for women and URM providers and students. Implicit bias and microaggression training and policies should be incorporated into medical education and resident curriculums. Similarly, educational resources and training must be made available to practicing physicians, faculty, and other providers through their institutions and places of employment. Equipping students and providers with the tools needed when microaggressions are witnessed or experienced demonstrates systemic-level accountability and communicates the importance of the issue. Furthermore, the development of retention plans and identification of mentors provide a support system and foster a culture of inclusion where recipients of microaggressions feel protected and valued. Increased feelings of inclusivity and belonging help bridge the gap created through microaggressions and implicit bias.

Final Thoughts

Despite an often covert nature, the detrimental effects of microaggressions are tangible and far reaching. As providers, we must strive to understand all categories of racism and expose the many ways prejudice manifests within medical training and clinical practice. It is our obligation to undertake the challenge of “making the ‘invisible’ visible” as we confront microaggressions and implicit bias to promote a safer and more inclusive medical community and workforce.¹⁹

As manifestations of overt racism and macroaggressions have gained increased visibility, there is a need for discussion of another expression of racism: microaggressions. Although racism classically is viewed as blatant structural, attitudinal, and behavioral prejudice, experts pose that the face of racism has evolved into a more covert insidious form. This form of racism was originally coined racial microaggressions by psychiatrist Chester M. Pierce, MD, 50 years ago.^1,2 Since that time, microaggressions have further expanded to describe “brief and commonplace daily verbal, behavioral, and environmental indignities, whether intentional or unintentional, that communicate hostile, derogatory, or negative racial, gender, sexual-orientation, and religious slights and insults to the target person or group.” ³ This article aims to define and depict examples of microaggressions in medicine, discuss the resulting harmful effects, and offer strategies to minimize and counter these negative ramifications.

What are microaggressions?

Microaggressions are behaviors that stem from implicit bias and occur at an interpersonal level. Implicit bias refers to unconscious stereotypes, assumptions, and beliefs held about an individual’s identity. One of the earliest microaggressions—invisibility—was characterized by Ralph Ellison in his novel Invisible Man. Ellison states, “I am invisible, understand, simply because people refuse to see me . . . When they approach me they see only my surroundings, themselves, or figments of their imagination—indeed, everything and anything except me.”⁴ This concept of invisibility is a primary microaggression faced by people of color.

In medicine, microaggressions and implicit bias may be encountered throughout medical training and clinical practice in interactions with colleagues, superiors, patients, and patients’ families.^5,6 Examples of microaggressions in medicine include demeaning comments, nonverbal disrespect, generalizations of social identity, assumption of nonphysician status, role- or credential-questioning behavior, explicit epithets, rejection of care, questioning or inquiries of ethnic/racial origin, and sexual harassment.⁷

An example of microaggressions in medicine was fully displayed when physician Tamika Cross described her experience of being turned away from helping an unresponsive passenger during a flight emergency.

[T]he flight attendant yells “call overhead for a physician on board.” I raised my hand to grab her attention. She said to me “oh no sweetie put [your] hand down, we are looking for actual physicians or nurses or some type of medical personnel, we don’t have time to talk to you” . . . Another “seasoned” white male approaches the row and says he is a physician as well. She says to me “thanks for your help but he can help us, and he has his credentials.”⁸

What are the effects of microaggressions?

Although microaggressions may be unconscious and unintentional by the offender, the negative ramifications are notable. Recent studies report that women and underrepresented minority (URM) medical students, residents, and physicians experience microaggressions and implicit bias at a higher prevalence and frequency compared with their male and non-URM counterparts.^7,9 Repetitive microaggressions are harmful to the health and safety of women and URM medical students, residents, physicians, other providers, and patients. The Table provides example scenarios of microaggressions in medicine categorized according to Berk.¹⁰

Microaggressions negatively impact physical, mental, and emotional well-being. Current data support that medical students and residents who experience microaggressions are more likely to report associated symptoms of burnout, depression, and suicidal thoughts.^11,12 Subjection to persistent bias can lead to minority status stress and racial battle fatigue, creating feelings of invisibility, isolation, exclusion, and loneliness for those impacted.^13,14

In the book Black Man in a White Coat: A Doctor’s Reflections on Race and Medicine, Damon Tweedy, MD, reflects on race in medicine. Tweedy notes his experience as a medical student when a professor mistakenly assumed he was a maintenance worker in the classroom. Tweedy describes how he internalized the exchange and, despite his success throughout the course of his medical training, combatted feelings of anxiety, self-doubt, and implied inferiority.¹⁵

Although microaggressions are harmful to one’s health, they also undermine the learning and teaching experience for students, residents, and faculty, and they detract from the larger goal of providing care for patients.¹¹ Frequent devaluing and questioning of an individual’s contributions, qualifications, and credentials based on identity can lower productivity and problem-solving abilities. These behaviors cultivate an unwelcome and hostile work/learning environment that is stressful and polarizing for the recipient.

Despite the heavy burden of microaggressions, most students, residents, and faculty physicians do not report incidents to their institutions and feel that training, resources, and policies to respond to bias adequately are lacking.⁷ As a result of implicit bias and microaggressions, women and URM medical students and providers are unable to focus solely on the practice of medicine. They are tasked with the additional burden of shouldering the emotional and cognitive complexities that microaggressions produce.¹⁶

What are strategies to reduce microaggressions in medicine?

To minimize the harmful effects of microaggressions, intervention strategies must be implemented that reduce the likelihood of the occurrence of microaggressions and challenge the stereotypes that undergird implicit bias. These strategies include cultivating allies, followed by demanding structural accountability. Allies are members of the majority group who collectively collaborate with members of the nonmajority group to effect change through the promotion of diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts.¹⁷ Cultivating allies involves building a network of collaboration among these groups and emphasizes education. Education is critical for allies to address microaggressions at the interpersonal level. This process of education involves personal reflection and self-awareness in exploring one’s biases, fears, and assumptions. Integral to this step is broadening one’s acceptance of different cultures, racial/ethnic groups, and identities. There must be a willingness to engage in difficult or uncomfortable conversations and a readiness to actively listen to concerns rather than perpetuating further harm through avoidance and dismissive or defensive behavior.¹⁸

Demanding structural accountability facilitates deconstruction of bias and microaggression at the larger systemic level. This strategy involves implicit bias and antiracism training, development of retention plans, and identification of mentors for women and URM providers and students. Implicit bias and microaggression training and policies should be incorporated into medical education and resident curriculums. Similarly, educational resources and training must be made available to practicing physicians, faculty, and other providers through their institutions and places of employment. Equipping students and providers with the tools needed when microaggressions are witnessed or experienced demonstrates systemic-level accountability and communicates the importance of the issue. Furthermore, the development of retention plans and identification of mentors provide a support system and foster a culture of inclusion where recipients of microaggressions feel protected and valued. Increased feelings of inclusivity and belonging help bridge the gap created through microaggressions and implicit bias.

Final Thoughts

Despite an often covert nature, the detrimental effects of microaggressions are tangible and far reaching. As providers, we must strive to understand all categories of racism and expose the many ways prejudice manifests within medical training and clinical practice. It is our obligation to undertake the challenge of “making the ‘invisible’ visible” as we confront microaggressions and implicit bias to promote a safer and more inclusive medical community and workforce.¹⁹

Dermatologic treatment of patients with skin of color offers specific challenges. Studies have reported structural, morphologic, and physiologic distinctions among different ethnic groups,¹ which may account for distinct clinical presentations of skin disease seen in patients with skin of color. Patients with skin of color are at increased risk for specific dermatologic conditions, such as postinflammatory hyperpigmentation, keloid development, and central centrifugal cicatricial alopecia.^2,3 Furthermore, although skin cancer is less prevalent in patients with skin of color, it often presents at a more advanced stage and with a worse prognosis compared to white patients.⁴

Individuals with skin of color make up the majority of the world’s population and a rapidly expanding portion of the US population. By the year 2044, more than half of all Americans are projected to belong to an ethnic group that is currently a minority. By 2060, the population of citizens identifying with 2 or more races will increase by 226%, the Asian population is projected to grow by 128%, the Hispanic population will increase by 115%, and the black population will increase by 42%.⁵ The racial and ethnic composition of the United States is evolving, and dermatologic care must evolve accordingly to address patients’ unique concerns. It is essential for future dermatologists to be knowledgeable about dermatologic conditions presenting in patients of various ethnic backgrounds.

Prior studies have demonstrated the need for increased exposure, education, and training in diseases pertaining to skin of color in US dermatology residency programs.^6-8 The aim of this study was to assess if dermatologists in-training feel that their residency curriculum sufficiently educates them on the needs of patients with skin of color.

Methods

A 10-question anonymous survey was emailed to 109 dermatology residency programs to evaluate the attitudes of dermatology residents about their exposure to patients with skin of color and their skin-of-color curriculum. The study included individuals 18 years or older who were current residents in a dermatology program accredited by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. Responses were measured on a 1 to 3 Likert scale, ranging from agree, neutral, and disagree. Data were analyzed using the Fisher exact test, and the statistical significance was set at P<.05.

Results

Forty-three dermatology residents completed the survey. Respondents self-selected their regions, with 8 (19%) from the Northeast (NE), 7 (16%) from the Southeast (SE), 12 (28%) from the Midwest (MW), 8 (19%) from the Southwest (SW), and 8 (18%) from the Northwest (NW)(Table 1). Overall, 31 (72%) respondents agreed that their practice treats a diverse patient population. Respondents who agreed most often were from the NE, SE, and SW. Less than two-thirds of respondents from the MW agreed, and only half of respondents from the NW agreed (Table 2). Although 37% of all respondents agreed that a dedicated multiethnic skin clinic is important for residents, 5 (63%) NE residents disagreed with this statement compared to 5 (42%) MW residents and 5 (63%) NW residents who agreed (P<.005). Overall, 39 (91%) respondents agreed that dedicated lectures on skin conditions in skin of color patients are important to gain competence in treating patients. Only 4 respondents were neutral to this question, 2 (17%) MW residents and 2 (25%) SW residents. When asked if reading textbook chapters on multiethnic skin is important to gain competence, 36 (83%) respondents agreed. Two respondents disagreed, 1 (13%) from the NE and 1 (8%) from the MW. Overall, 23% of respondents agreed that a rotation dedicated to skin of color is important to build competency. There was a significant difference in responses between the NE and MW (P=.032) and between the NE and NW (P=.019). Furthermore, 19 (44%) respondents agreed that having a faculty member or departmental expert is important for residents to gain competence in treating conditions affecting skin of color. Again, there was a significant difference in responses between the NE and MW (P=.003) and between the SE and MW (P=.009).

When asked the number of hours of lecture per month necessary to gain competence in conditions affecting patients with skin of color, 67% agreed that 1 to 5 hours was sufficient (Table 3). There were significant differences in the responses between the NE and SE (P=.024) and the SE and MW (P=.007). Of all respondents, 53% reported 1 to 5 months of clinical training are needed to gain competence in treating conditions affecting patients with skin of color, with significant differences in responses between the NE and MW (P<.001), the NE and SW (P=.019), and the SE and MW (P=.015)(Table 4).

Comment

Responses varied by practicing region. Less ethnically diverse regions, such as the MW and NW, were more likely to agree that dedicated clinics and rotations are important to gain competence compared to more ethnically diverse regions such as the NE, SE, and SW. Overall, more residents reported that dedicated lectures and textbook chapters were important to gain competency compared to dedicated clinics or rotations.

Although interactive lectures and textbook readings are important for obtaining a foundational understanding of dermatologic disease, they cannot substitute for clinical interactions and hands-on experience treating patients with skin of color.⁹ Not only do clinical interactions encourage independent reading and the study of encountered diagnoses, but intercommunication with patients may have a more profound and lasting impact on residents’ education.

Different regions of the United States have varying distributions of patients with skin of color, and dermatology residency program training reflects these disparities.⁶ In areas of less diversity, dermatology residents examine, diagnose, and treat substantially fewer patients with skin of color. The desire for more diverse training supports the prior findings of Nijhawan et al⁶ and is reflected in the responses we received in our study, whereby residents from the less ethnically diversified regions of the MW and NW were more likely to agree that clinics and rotations were necessary for training in preparation to sufficiently address the needs of patients with skin of color.

One way to compensate for the lack of ethnic diversity encountered in areas such as the MW and NW would be to develop educational programs featuring experts on skin of color.⁶ These specialists would not only train dermatology residents in areas of the country currently lacking ethnic diversity but also expand the expertise for treating patients with skin of color. Additionally, dedicated multiethnic skin clinics and externships devoted solely to treating patients with skin of color could be encouraged for residency training.⁶ Finally, community outreach through volunteer clinics may provide residents exposure to patients with skin of color seeking dermatologic care.¹⁰

This study was limited by the small number of respondents, but we were able to extract important trends and data from the collected responses. It is possible that respondents felt strongly about topics involving patients with skin of color, and the results were skewed to reflect individual bias. Additional limitations included not asking respondents for program names and population density (eg, urban, suburban, rural). Future studies should be directed toward analyzing how the diversity of the local population influences training in patients with skin of color, comparing program directors’ perceptions with residents’ perceptions on training in skin of color, and assessing patient perception of residents’ training in skin of color.

Conclusion

In the last decade it has become increasingly apparent that the US population is diversifying and that patients with skin of color will comprise a substantial proportion of the future population,^8,11 which emphasizes the need for dermatology residency programs to ensure that residents receive adequate training and exposure to patients with skin of color as well as the distinct skin diseases seen more commonly in these populations.¹²

Dermatologic treatment of patients with skin of color offers specific challenges. Studies have reported structural, morphologic, and physiologic distinctions among different ethnic groups,¹ which may account for distinct clinical presentations of skin disease seen in patients with skin of color. Patients with skin of color are at increased risk for specific dermatologic conditions, such as postinflammatory hyperpigmentation, keloid development, and central centrifugal cicatricial alopecia.^2,3 Furthermore, although skin cancer is less prevalent in patients with skin of color, it often presents at a more advanced stage and with a worse prognosis compared to white patients.⁴

Individuals with skin of color make up the majority of the world’s population and a rapidly expanding portion of the US population. By the year 2044, more than half of all Americans are projected to belong to an ethnic group that is currently a minority. By 2060, the population of citizens identifying with 2 or more races will increase by 226%, the Asian population is projected to grow by 128%, the Hispanic population will increase by 115%, and the black population will increase by 42%.⁵ The racial and ethnic composition of the United States is evolving, and dermatologic care must evolve accordingly to address patients’ unique concerns. It is essential for future dermatologists to be knowledgeable about dermatologic conditions presenting in patients of various ethnic backgrounds.

Prior studies have demonstrated the need for increased exposure, education, and training in diseases pertaining to skin of color in US dermatology residency programs.^6-8 The aim of this study was to assess if dermatologists in-training feel that their residency curriculum sufficiently educates them on the needs of patients with skin of color.

Methods

A 10-question anonymous survey was emailed to 109 dermatology residency programs to evaluate the attitudes of dermatology residents about their exposure to patients with skin of color and their skin-of-color curriculum. The study included individuals 18 years or older who were current residents in a dermatology program accredited by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. Responses were measured on a 1 to 3 Likert scale, ranging from agree, neutral, and disagree. Data were analyzed using the Fisher exact test, and the statistical significance was set at P<.05.

Results

Forty-three dermatology residents completed the survey. Respondents self-selected their regions, with 8 (19%) from the Northeast (NE), 7 (16%) from the Southeast (SE), 12 (28%) from the Midwest (MW), 8 (19%) from the Southwest (SW), and 8 (18%) from the Northwest (NW)(Table 1). Overall, 31 (72%) respondents agreed that their practice treats a diverse patient population. Respondents who agreed most often were from the NE, SE, and SW. Less than two-thirds of respondents from the MW agreed, and only half of respondents from the NW agreed (Table 2). Although 37% of all respondents agreed that a dedicated multiethnic skin clinic is important for residents, 5 (63%) NE residents disagreed with this statement compared to 5 (42%) MW residents and 5 (63%) NW residents who agreed (P<.005). Overall, 39 (91%) respondents agreed that dedicated lectures on skin conditions in skin of color patients are important to gain competence in treating patients. Only 4 respondents were neutral to this question, 2 (17%) MW residents and 2 (25%) SW residents. When asked if reading textbook chapters on multiethnic skin is important to gain competence, 36 (83%) respondents agreed. Two respondents disagreed, 1 (13%) from the NE and 1 (8%) from the MW. Overall, 23% of respondents agreed that a rotation dedicated to skin of color is important to build competency. There was a significant difference in responses between the NE and MW (P=.032) and between the NE and NW (P=.019). Furthermore, 19 (44%) respondents agreed that having a faculty member or departmental expert is important for residents to gain competence in treating conditions affecting skin of color. Again, there was a significant difference in responses between the NE and MW (P=.003) and between the SE and MW (P=.009).

When asked the number of hours of lecture per month necessary to gain competence in conditions affecting patients with skin of color, 67% agreed that 1 to 5 hours was sufficient (Table 3). There were significant differences in the responses between the NE and SE (P=.024) and the SE and MW (P=.007). Of all respondents, 53% reported 1 to 5 months of clinical training are needed to gain competence in treating conditions affecting patients with skin of color, with significant differences in responses between the NE and MW (P<.001), the NE and SW (P=.019), and the SE and MW (P=.015)(Table 4).

Comment

Responses varied by practicing region. Less ethnically diverse regions, such as the MW and NW, were more likely to agree that dedicated clinics and rotations are important to gain competence compared to more ethnically diverse regions such as the NE, SE, and SW. Overall, more residents reported that dedicated lectures and textbook chapters were important to gain competency compared to dedicated clinics or rotations.

Although interactive lectures and textbook readings are important for obtaining a foundational understanding of dermatologic disease, they cannot substitute for clinical interactions and hands-on experience treating patients with skin of color.⁹ Not only do clinical interactions encourage independent reading and the study of encountered diagnoses, but intercommunication with patients may have a more profound and lasting impact on residents’ education.

Different regions of the United States have varying distributions of patients with skin of color, and dermatology residency program training reflects these disparities.⁶ In areas of less diversity, dermatology residents examine, diagnose, and treat substantially fewer patients with skin of color. The desire for more diverse training supports the prior findings of Nijhawan et al⁶ and is reflected in the responses we received in our study, whereby residents from the less ethnically diversified regions of the MW and NW were more likely to agree that clinics and rotations were necessary for training in preparation to sufficiently address the needs of patients with skin of color.

One way to compensate for the lack of ethnic diversity encountered in areas such as the MW and NW would be to develop educational programs featuring experts on skin of color.⁶ These specialists would not only train dermatology residents in areas of the country currently lacking ethnic diversity but also expand the expertise for treating patients with skin of color. Additionally, dedicated multiethnic skin clinics and externships devoted solely to treating patients with skin of color could be encouraged for residency training.⁶ Finally, community outreach through volunteer clinics may provide residents exposure to patients with skin of color seeking dermatologic care.¹⁰

This study was limited by the small number of respondents, but we were able to extract important trends and data from the collected responses. It is possible that respondents felt strongly about topics involving patients with skin of color, and the results were skewed to reflect individual bias. Additional limitations included not asking respondents for program names and population density (eg, urban, suburban, rural). Future studies should be directed toward analyzing how the diversity of the local population influences training in patients with skin of color, comparing program directors’ perceptions with residents’ perceptions on training in skin of color, and assessing patient perception of residents’ training in skin of color.

Conclusion

In the last decade it has become increasingly apparent that the US population is diversifying and that patients with skin of color will comprise a substantial proportion of the future population,^8,11 which emphasizes the need for dermatology residency programs to ensure that residents receive adequate training and exposure to patients with skin of color as well as the distinct skin diseases seen more commonly in these populations.¹²

Dermatologic treatment of patients with skin of color offers specific challenges. Studies have reported structural, morphologic, and physiologic distinctions among different ethnic groups,¹ which may account for distinct clinical presentations of skin disease seen in patients with skin of color. Patients with skin of color are at increased risk for specific dermatologic conditions, such as postinflammatory hyperpigmentation, keloid development, and central centrifugal cicatricial alopecia.^2,3 Furthermore, although skin cancer is less prevalent in patients with skin of color, it often presents at a more advanced stage and with a worse prognosis compared to white patients.⁴

Individuals with skin of color make up the majority of the world’s population and a rapidly expanding portion of the US population. By the year 2044, more than half of all Americans are projected to belong to an ethnic group that is currently a minority. By 2060, the population of citizens identifying with 2 or more races will increase by 226%, the Asian population is projected to grow by 128%, the Hispanic population will increase by 115%, and the black population will increase by 42%.⁵ The racial and ethnic composition of the United States is evolving, and dermatologic care must evolve accordingly to address patients’ unique concerns. It is essential for future dermatologists to be knowledgeable about dermatologic conditions presenting in patients of various ethnic backgrounds.

Prior studies have demonstrated the need for increased exposure, education, and training in diseases pertaining to skin of color in US dermatology residency programs.^6-8 The aim of this study was to assess if dermatologists in-training feel that their residency curriculum sufficiently educates them on the needs of patients with skin of color.

Methods

A 10-question anonymous survey was emailed to 109 dermatology residency programs to evaluate the attitudes of dermatology residents about their exposure to patients with skin of color and their skin-of-color curriculum. The study included individuals 18 years or older who were current residents in a dermatology program accredited by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. Responses were measured on a 1 to 3 Likert scale, ranging from agree, neutral, and disagree. Data were analyzed using the Fisher exact test, and the statistical significance was set at P<.05.

Results

Forty-three dermatology residents completed the survey. Respondents self-selected their regions, with 8 (19%) from the Northeast (NE), 7 (16%) from the Southeast (SE), 12 (28%) from the Midwest (MW), 8 (19%) from the Southwest (SW), and 8 (18%) from the Northwest (NW)(Table 1). Overall, 31 (72%) respondents agreed that their practice treats a diverse patient population. Respondents who agreed most often were from the NE, SE, and SW. Less than two-thirds of respondents from the MW agreed, and only half of respondents from the NW agreed (Table 2). Although 37% of all respondents agreed that a dedicated multiethnic skin clinic is important for residents, 5 (63%) NE residents disagreed with this statement compared to 5 (42%) MW residents and 5 (63%) NW residents who agreed (P<.005). Overall, 39 (91%) respondents agreed that dedicated lectures on skin conditions in skin of color patients are important to gain competence in treating patients. Only 4 respondents were neutral to this question, 2 (17%) MW residents and 2 (25%) SW residents. When asked if reading textbook chapters on multiethnic skin is important to gain competence, 36 (83%) respondents agreed. Two respondents disagreed, 1 (13%) from the NE and 1 (8%) from the MW. Overall, 23% of respondents agreed that a rotation dedicated to skin of color is important to build competency. There was a significant difference in responses between the NE and MW (P=.032) and between the NE and NW (P=.019). Furthermore, 19 (44%) respondents agreed that having a faculty member or departmental expert is important for residents to gain competence in treating conditions affecting skin of color. Again, there was a significant difference in responses between the NE and MW (P=.003) and between the SE and MW (P=.009).

When asked the number of hours of lecture per month necessary to gain competence in conditions affecting patients with skin of color, 67% agreed that 1 to 5 hours was sufficient (Table 3). There were significant differences in the responses between the NE and SE (P=.024) and the SE and MW (P=.007). Of all respondents, 53% reported 1 to 5 months of clinical training are needed to gain competence in treating conditions affecting patients with skin of color, with significant differences in responses between the NE and MW (P<.001), the NE and SW (P=.019), and the SE and MW (P=.015)(Table 4).

Comment

Responses varied by practicing region. Less ethnically diverse regions, such as the MW and NW, were more likely to agree that dedicated clinics and rotations are important to gain competence compared to more ethnically diverse regions such as the NE, SE, and SW. Overall, more residents reported that dedicated lectures and textbook chapters were important to gain competency compared to dedicated clinics or rotations.

Although interactive lectures and textbook readings are important for obtaining a foundational understanding of dermatologic disease, they cannot substitute for clinical interactions and hands-on experience treating patients with skin of color.⁹ Not only do clinical interactions encourage independent reading and the study of encountered diagnoses, but intercommunication with patients may have a more profound and lasting impact on residents’ education.

Different regions of the United States have varying distributions of patients with skin of color, and dermatology residency program training reflects these disparities.⁶ In areas of less diversity, dermatology residents examine, diagnose, and treat substantially fewer patients with skin of color. The desire for more diverse training supports the prior findings of Nijhawan et al⁶ and is reflected in the responses we received in our study, whereby residents from the less ethnically diversified regions of the MW and NW were more likely to agree that clinics and rotations were necessary for training in preparation to sufficiently address the needs of patients with skin of color.

One way to compensate for the lack of ethnic diversity encountered in areas such as the MW and NW would be to develop educational programs featuring experts on skin of color.⁶ These specialists would not only train dermatology residents in areas of the country currently lacking ethnic diversity but also expand the expertise for treating patients with skin of color. Additionally, dedicated multiethnic skin clinics and externships devoted solely to treating patients with skin of color could be encouraged for residency training.⁶ Finally, community outreach through volunteer clinics may provide residents exposure to patients with skin of color seeking dermatologic care.¹⁰

This study was limited by the small number of respondents, but we were able to extract important trends and data from the collected responses. It is possible that respondents felt strongly about topics involving patients with skin of color, and the results were skewed to reflect individual bias. Additional limitations included not asking respondents for program names and population density (eg, urban, suburban, rural). Future studies should be directed toward analyzing how the diversity of the local population influences training in patients with skin of color, comparing program directors’ perceptions with residents’ perceptions on training in skin of color, and assessing patient perception of residents’ training in skin of color.

Conclusion

In the last decade it has become increasingly apparent that the US population is diversifying and that patients with skin of color will comprise a substantial proportion of the future population,^8,11 which emphasizes the need for dermatology residency programs to ensure that residents receive adequate training and exposure to patients with skin of color as well as the distinct skin diseases seen more commonly in these populations.¹²

Data are limited on the management of atopic dermatitis (AD) in adolescents, particularly in patients with skin of color, making it important to identify factors that may improve AD management in this population. Comorbid conditions (eg, acne, postinflammatory hyperpigmentation [PIH]), extracurricular activities (eg, athletics), and experimentation with cosmetics in adolescents, all of which can undermine treatment efficacy and medication adherence, make it particularly challenging to devise a therapeutic regimen in this patient population. We review the management of AD in black adolescents, with special consideration of concomitant treatment of acne vulgaris (AV) as well as lifestyle and social choices (Table).

Prevalence and Epidemiology

Atopic dermatitis affects 13% to 25% of children and 2% to 10% of adults.^1,2 Population‐based studies in the United States show a higher prevalence of AD in black children (19.3%) compared to European American (EA) children (16.1%).^3,4

AD in Black Adolescents

Atopic dermatitis is a common skin condition that is defined as a chronic, pruritic, inflammatory dermatosis with recurrent scaling, papules, and plaques (Figure) that usually develop during infancy and early childhood.³ Although AD severity improves for some patients in adolescence, it can be a lifelong issue affecting performance in academic and occupational settings.⁵ One US study of 8015 children found that there are racial and ethnic disparities in school absences among children (age range, 2–17 years) with AD, with children with skin of color being absent more often than white children.⁶ The same study noted that black children had a 1.5-fold higher chance of being absent 6 days over a 6-month school period compared to white children. It is postulated that AD has a greater impact on quality of life (QOL) in children with skin of color, resulting in the increased number of school absences in this population.⁶

The origin of AD currently is thought to be complex and can involve skin barrier dysfunction, environmental factors, microbiome effects, genetic predisposition, and immune dysregulation.^1,4 Atopic dermatitis is a heterogeneous disease with variations in the prevalence, genetic background, and immune activation patterns across racial groups.⁴ It is now understood to be an immune-mediated disease with multiple inflammatory pathways, with type 2–associated inflammation being a primary pathway. Patients with AD have strong helper T cell (T_H2) activation, and black patients with AD have higher IgE serum levels as well as absent T_H17/T_H1 activation.⁴

Atopic dermatitis currently is seen as a defect of the epidermal barrier, with variable clinical manifestations and expressivity.⁷ Filaggrin is an epidermal barrier protein, encoded by the FLG gene, and plays a major role in barrier function by regulating pH and promoting hydration of the skin.⁴ Loss of function of the FLG gene is the most well-studied genetic risk factor for developing AD, and this mutation is seen in patients with more severe and persistent AD in addition to patients with more skin infections and allergic sensitizations.^3,4 However, in the skin of color population, FLG mutations are 6 times less common than in the EA population, despite the fact that AD is more prevalent in patients of African descent.⁴ Therefore, the role of the FLG loss-of-function mutation and AD is not as well defined in black patients, and some researchers have found no association.³ The FLG loss-of-function mutation seems to play a smaller role in black patients than in EA patients, and other genes may be involved in skin barrier dysfunction.^3,4 In a small study of patients with mild AD compared to nonaffected patients, those with AD had lower total ceramide levels in the stratum corneum of affected sites than normal skin sites in healthy individuals.⁸

Particular disturbances in the gut microbiome have the possibility of impacting the development of AD.⁹ Additionally, the development of AD may be influenced by the skin microbiome, which can change depending on body site, with fungal organisms thought to make up a large proportion of the microbiome of patients with AD. In patients with AD, there is a lack of microbial diversity and an overgrowth of Staphylococcus aureus.⁹

Diagnosis

Clinicians diagnose AD based on clinical characteristics, and the lack of objective criteria can hinder diagnosis.¹ Thus, diagnosing AD in children with dark skin can pose a particular challenge given the varied clinical presentation of AD across skin types. Severe cases of AD may not be diagnosed or treated adequately in deeply pigmented children because erythema, a defining characteristic of AD, may be hard to identify in darker skin types.¹⁰ Furthermore, clinical erythema scores among black children may be “strongly” underestimated using scoring systems such as Eczema Area and Severity Index and SCORing Atopic Dermatitis.⁴ It is estimated that the risk for severe AD may be 6 times higher in black children compared to white children.¹⁰ Additionally, patients with skin of color can present with more treatment-resistant AD.⁴

Treatment of AD

Current treatment is focused on restoring epidermal barrier function, often with topical agents, such as moisturizers containing different amounts of emollients, occlusives, and humectants; corticosteroids; calcineurin inhibitors; and antimicrobials. Emollients such as glycol stearate, glyceryl stearate, and soy sterols function as lubricants, softening the skin. Occlusive agents include petrolatum, dimethicone, and mineral oil; they act by forming a layer to slow evaporation of water. Humectants including glycerol, lactic acid, and urea function by promoting water retention.¹¹ For acute flares, mid- to high-potency topical corticosteroids are recommended. Also, topical calcineurin inhibitors such as tacrolimus and pimecrolimus may be used alone or in combination with topical steroids. Finally, bleach baths and topical mupirocin applied to the nares also have proved helpful in moderate to severe AD with secondary bacterial infections.¹¹ Phototherapy can be used in adult and pediatric patients with acute and chronic AD if traditional treatments have failed.²

Systemic agents are indicated and recommended for the subset of adult and pediatric patients in whom optimized topical regimens and/or phototherapy do not adequately provide disease control or when QOL is substantially impacted. The systemic agents effective in the pediatric population include cyclosporine, azathioprine, mycophenolate mofetil, and possibly methotrexate.¹¹ Dupilumab recently was approved by the US Food and Drug Administration for patients 12 years and older with moderate to severe AD whose disease is not well controlled with topical medications.

Patients with AD are predisposed to secondary bacterial and viral infections because of their dysfunctional skin barrier; these infections most commonly are caused by S aureus and herpes simplex virus, respectively.² Systemic antibiotics are only recommended for patients with AD when there is clinical evidence of bacterial infection. In patients with evidence of eczema herpeticum, systemic antiviral agents should be used to treat the underlying herpes simplex virus infection.² Atopic dermatitis typically has been studied in white patients; however, patients with skin of color have higher frequencies of treatment-resistant AD. Further research on treatment efficacy for AD in this patient population is needed, as data are limited.⁴

Treatment of AV in Patients With AD

Two of the most prevalent skin diseases affecting the pediatric population are AD and AV, and both can remarkably impact QOL.¹² Acne is one of the most common reasons for adolescent patients to seek dermatologic care, including patients with skin of color (Fitzpatrick skin types IV to VI).¹³ Thus, it is to be expected that many black adolescents with AD also will have AV. For mild to moderate acne in patients with skin of color, topical retinoids and benzoyl peroxide typically are first line.¹³ These medications can be problematic for patients with AD, as retinoids and many other acne treatments can cause dryness, which may exacerbate AD.

Moisturizers containing ceramide can be a helpful adjunctive therapy in treating acne,¹⁴ especially in patients with AD. Modifications to application of acne medications, such as using topical retinoids every other night or mixing them with moisturizers to minimize dryness, may be beneficial to these patients. Dapsone gel 7.5% used daily also may be an option for adolescents with AD and AV. A double-blind, vehicle-controlled study demonstrated that dapsone is safe and effective for patients 12 years and older with moderate acne, and patients with Fitzpatrick skin types IV to VI rated local scaling, erythema, dryness, and stinging/burning as “none” in the study.¹⁵ Another potentially helpful topical agent in patients with AD and AV is sulfacetamide, as it is not likely to cause dryness of the skin. In a small study, sodium sulfacetamide 10% and sulfur 5% in an emollient foam vehicle showed no residual film or sulfur smell and resulted in acne reduction of 50%.¹⁶

Patients with skin of color often experience PIH in AD and acne or hypopigmentation from inflammatory dermatoses including AD.^17,18 In addition to the dryness from AD and topical retinoid use, patients with skin of color may develop irritant contact dermatitis, thus leading to PIH.¹³ Dryness and irritant contact dermatitis also can be seen with the use of benzoyl peroxide in black patients. Because of these effects, gentle moisturizers are recommended, and both benzoyl peroxide and retinoids should be initiated at lower doses in patients with skin of color.¹³

For patients with severe nodulocystic acne, isotretinoin is the treatment of choice in patients with skin of color,¹³ but there is a dearth of clinical studies addressing complications seen in black adolescents on this treatment, especially with respect to those with AD. Of note, systemic antibiotics typically are initiated before isotretinoin; however, this strategy is falling out of favor due to concern for antibiotic resistance with long-term use.¹⁹

Impact of Athletics on AD in Black Adolescents

Because of the exacerbating effects of perspiration and heat causing itch and irritation in patients with AD, it is frequently advised that pediatric patients limit their participation in athletics because of the exacerbating effects of strenuous physical exercise on their disease.¹² In one study, 429 pediatric patients or their parents/guardians completed QOL questionnaires; 89% of patients 15 years and younger with severe AD reported that their disease was impacted by athletics and outdoor activities, and 86% of these pediatric patients with severe AD responded that their social lives and leisure activities were impacted.²⁰ Because adolescents often are involved in athletics or have mandatory physical education classes, AD may be isolating and may have a severe impact on self-esteem.

Aggressive treatment of AD with topical and systemic medications may be helpful in adolescents who may be reluctant to participate in sports because of teasing, bullying, or worsening of symptoms with heat or sweating.²¹ Now that dupilumab is available for adolescents, there is a chance that patients with severe and/or recalcitrant disease managed on this medication can achieve better control of their symptoms without the laboratory requirement of methotrexate and the difficulties of topical medication application, allowing them to engage in mandatory athletic classes as well as desired organized sports.

Use of Cosmetics for AD

Many adolescents experiment with cosmetics, and those with AD may use cosmetic products to cover hyperpigmented or hypopigmented lesions.¹⁸ In patients with active AD or increased sensitivity to allergens in cosmetic products, use of makeup can be a contributing factor for AD flares. Acne associated with cosmetics is especially important to consider in darker-skinned patients who may use makeup that is opaque and contains oil to conceal acne or PIH.

Allergens can be present in both cosmetics and pharmaceutical topical agents, and a Brazilian study found that approximately 89% of 813 prescription and nonprescription products (eg, topical drugs, sunscreens, moisturizers, soaps, cleansing lotions, shampoos, cosmeceuticals) contained allergens.²² Patients with AD have a higher prevalence of contact sensitization to fragrances, including balsam of Peru.²³ Some AD treatments that contain fragrances have caused further skin issues in a few patients. In one case series, 3 pediatric patients developed allergic contact dermatitis to Myroxylon pereirae (balsam of Peru) when using topical treatments for their AD, and their symptoms of scalp inflammation and alopecia resolved with discontinuation.²³

In a Dutch study, sensitization to Fragrance Mix I and M pereirae as well as other ingredients (eg, lanolin alcohol, Amerchol™ L 101 [a lanolin product]) was notably more common in pediatric patients with AD than in patients without AD; however, no data on patients with skin of color were included in this study.²⁴

Because of the increased risk of sensitization to fragrances and other ingredients in patients with AD as well as the high percentage of allergens in prescription and nonprescription products, it is important to discuss all personal care products that patients may be using, not just their cosmetic products. Also, patch testing may be helpful in determining true allergens in some patients. Patch testing is recommended for patients with treatment-resistant AD, and a recent study suggested it should be done prior to long-term use of immunosuppressive agents.²⁵ Increased steroid phobia and a push toward alternative medicines are leading both patients with AD and guardians of children with AD to look for other forms of moisturization, such as olive oil, coconut oil, sunflower seed oil, and shea butter, to decrease transepidermal water loss.^26,27 An important factor in AD treatment efficacy is patient acceptability in using what is recommended.²⁷ One study showed there was no difference in efficacy or acceptability in using a cream containing shea butter extract vs the ceramide-precursor product.²⁷ Current data show olive oil may exacerbate dry skin and AD,²⁶ and recommendation of any over-the-counter oils and butters in patients with AD should be made with great caution, as many of these products contain fragrances and other potential allergens.

Alternative Therapies for AD

Patients with AD often seek alternative or integrative treatment options, including dietary modifications and holistic remedies. Studies investigating the role of vitamins and supplements in treating AD are limited by sample size.²⁸ However, there is some evidence that may support supplementation with vitamins D and E in addressing AD symptoms. The use of probiotics in treating AD is controversial, but there are studies suggesting that the use of probiotics may prove beneficial in preventing infantile AD.²⁸ Additionally, findings from an ex vivo and in vitro study show that some conditions, including AD and acne, may benefit from the same probiotics, despite the differences in these two diseases. Both AD and acne have inflammatory and skin dysbiosis characteristics, which may be the common thread leading to both conditions potentially responding to treatment with probiotics.²⁹

Preliminary evidence indicates that supplements containing fatty acids such as docosahexaenoic acid, sea buckthorn oil, and hemp seed oil may decrease the severity of AD.²⁸ In a 20-week, randomized, single-blind, crossover study published in 2005, dietary hemp seed oil showed an improvement of clinical symptoms, including dry skin and itchiness, in patients with AD.³⁰

In light of recent legalization in several states, patients may turn to use of cannabinoid products to manage AD. In a systematic review, cannabinoid use was reportedly a therapeutic option in the treatment of AD and AV; however, the data are based on preclinical work, and there are no randomized, placebo-controlled studies to support the use of cannabinoids.³¹ Furthermore, there is great concern that use of these products in adolescents is an even larger unknown.

Final Thoughts

Eighty percent of children diagnosed with AD experience symptom improvement before their early teens³²; for those with AD during their preteen and teenage years, there can be psychological ramifications, as teenagers with AD report having fewer friends, are less socially involved, participate in fewer sports, and are absent from classes more often than their peers.⁵ In black patients with AD, school absences are even more common.⁶ Given the social and emotional impact of AD on patients with skin of color, it is imperative to treat the condition appropriately.³³ There are areas of opportunity for further research on alternate dosing of existing treatments for AV in patients with AD, further recommendations for adolescent athletes with AD, and which cosmetic and alternative medicine products may be beneficial for this population to improve their QOL.

Providers should discuss medical management in a broader context considering patients’ extracurricular activities, treatment vehicle preferences, expectations, and personal care habits. It also is important to address the many possible factors that may influence treatment adherence early on, particularly in adolescents, as these could be barriers to treatment. This article highlights considerations for treating AD and comorbid conditions that may further complicate treatment in adolescent patients with skin of color. The information provided should serve as a guide in initial counseling and management of AD in adolescents with skin of color.

Data are limited on the management of atopic dermatitis (AD) in adolescents, particularly in patients with skin of color, making it important to identify factors that may improve AD management in this population. Comorbid conditions (eg, acne, postinflammatory hyperpigmentation [PIH]), extracurricular activities (eg, athletics), and experimentation with cosmetics in adolescents, all of which can undermine treatment efficacy and medication adherence, make it particularly challenging to devise a therapeutic regimen in this patient population. We review the management of AD in black adolescents, with special consideration of concomitant treatment of acne vulgaris (AV) as well as lifestyle and social choices (Table).

Prevalence and Epidemiology

Atopic dermatitis affects 13% to 25% of children and 2% to 10% of adults.^1,2 Population‐based studies in the United States show a higher prevalence of AD in black children (19.3%) compared to European American (EA) children (16.1%).^3,4

AD in Black Adolescents

Atopic dermatitis is a common skin condition that is defined as a chronic, pruritic, inflammatory dermatosis with recurrent scaling, papules, and plaques (Figure) that usually develop during infancy and early childhood.³ Although AD severity improves for some patients in adolescence, it can be a lifelong issue affecting performance in academic and occupational settings.⁵ One US study of 8015 children found that there are racial and ethnic disparities in school absences among children (age range, 2–17 years) with AD, with children with skin of color being absent more often than white children.⁶ The same study noted that black children had a 1.5-fold higher chance of being absent 6 days over a 6-month school period compared to white children. It is postulated that AD has a greater impact on quality of life (QOL) in children with skin of color, resulting in the increased number of school absences in this population.⁶

The origin of AD currently is thought to be complex and can involve skin barrier dysfunction, environmental factors, microbiome effects, genetic predisposition, and immune dysregulation.^1,4 Atopic dermatitis is a heterogeneous disease with variations in the prevalence, genetic background, and immune activation patterns across racial groups.⁴ It is now understood to be an immune-mediated disease with multiple inflammatory pathways, with type 2–associated inflammation being a primary pathway. Patients with AD have strong helper T cell (T_H2) activation, and black patients with AD have higher IgE serum levels as well as absent T_H17/T_H1 activation.⁴

Atopic dermatitis currently is seen as a defect of the epidermal barrier, with variable clinical manifestations and expressivity.⁷ Filaggrin is an epidermal barrier protein, encoded by the FLG gene, and plays a major role in barrier function by regulating pH and promoting hydration of the skin.⁴ Loss of function of the FLG gene is the most well-studied genetic risk factor for developing AD, and this mutation is seen in patients with more severe and persistent AD in addition to patients with more skin infections and allergic sensitizations.^3,4 However, in the skin of color population, FLG mutations are 6 times less common than in the EA population, despite the fact that AD is more prevalent in patients of African descent.⁴ Therefore, the role of the FLG loss-of-function mutation and AD is not as well defined in black patients, and some researchers have found no association.³ The FLG loss-of-function mutation seems to play a smaller role in black patients than in EA patients, and other genes may be involved in skin barrier dysfunction.^3,4 In a small study of patients with mild AD compared to nonaffected patients, those with AD had lower total ceramide levels in the stratum corneum of affected sites than normal skin sites in healthy individuals.⁸

Particular disturbances in the gut microbiome have the possibility of impacting the development of AD.⁹ Additionally, the development of AD may be influenced by the skin microbiome, which can change depending on body site, with fungal organisms thought to make up a large proportion of the microbiome of patients with AD. In patients with AD, there is a lack of microbial diversity and an overgrowth of Staphylococcus aureus.⁹

Diagnosis

Clinicians diagnose AD based on clinical characteristics, and the lack of objective criteria can hinder diagnosis.¹ Thus, diagnosing AD in children with dark skin can pose a particular challenge given the varied clinical presentation of AD across skin types. Severe cases of AD may not be diagnosed or treated adequately in deeply pigmented children because erythema, a defining characteristic of AD, may be hard to identify in darker skin types.¹⁰ Furthermore, clinical erythema scores among black children may be “strongly” underestimated using scoring systems such as Eczema Area and Severity Index and SCORing Atopic Dermatitis.⁴ It is estimated that the risk for severe AD may be 6 times higher in black children compared to white children.¹⁰ Additionally, patients with skin of color can present with more treatment-resistant AD.⁴

Treatment of AD

Current treatment is focused on restoring epidermal barrier function, often with topical agents, such as moisturizers containing different amounts of emollients, occlusives, and humectants; corticosteroids; calcineurin inhibitors; and antimicrobials. Emollients such as glycol stearate, glyceryl stearate, and soy sterols function as lubricants, softening the skin. Occlusive agents include petrolatum, dimethicone, and mineral oil; they act by forming a layer to slow evaporation of water. Humectants including glycerol, lactic acid, and urea function by promoting water retention.¹¹ For acute flares, mid- to high-potency topical corticosteroids are recommended. Also, topical calcineurin inhibitors such as tacrolimus and pimecrolimus may be used alone or in combination with topical steroids. Finally, bleach baths and topical mupirocin applied to the nares also have proved helpful in moderate to severe AD with secondary bacterial infections.¹¹ Phototherapy can be used in adult and pediatric patients with acute and chronic AD if traditional treatments have failed.²

Systemic agents are indicated and recommended for the subset of adult and pediatric patients in whom optimized topical regimens and/or phototherapy do not adequately provide disease control or when QOL is substantially impacted. The systemic agents effective in the pediatric population include cyclosporine, azathioprine, mycophenolate mofetil, and possibly methotrexate.¹¹ Dupilumab recently was approved by the US Food and Drug Administration for patients 12 years and older with moderate to severe AD whose disease is not well controlled with topical medications.

Patients with AD are predisposed to secondary bacterial and viral infections because of their dysfunctional skin barrier; these infections most commonly are caused by S aureus and herpes simplex virus, respectively.² Systemic antibiotics are only recommended for patients with AD when there is clinical evidence of bacterial infection. In patients with evidence of eczema herpeticum, systemic antiviral agents should be used to treat the underlying herpes simplex virus infection.² Atopic dermatitis typically has been studied in white patients; however, patients with skin of color have higher frequencies of treatment-resistant AD. Further research on treatment efficacy for AD in this patient population is needed, as data are limited.⁴

Treatment of AV in Patients With AD

Two of the most prevalent skin diseases affecting the pediatric population are AD and AV, and both can remarkably impact QOL.¹² Acne is one of the most common reasons for adolescent patients to seek dermatologic care, including patients with skin of color (Fitzpatrick skin types IV to VI).¹³ Thus, it is to be expected that many black adolescents with AD also will have AV. For mild to moderate acne in patients with skin of color, topical retinoids and benzoyl peroxide typically are first line.¹³ These medications can be problematic for patients with AD, as retinoids and many other acne treatments can cause dryness, which may exacerbate AD.

Moisturizers containing ceramide can be a helpful adjunctive therapy in treating acne,¹⁴ especially in patients with AD. Modifications to application of acne medications, such as using topical retinoids every other night or mixing them with moisturizers to minimize dryness, may be beneficial to these patients. Dapsone gel 7.5% used daily also may be an option for adolescents with AD and AV. A double-blind, vehicle-controlled study demonstrated that dapsone is safe and effective for patients 12 years and older with moderate acne, and patients with Fitzpatrick skin types IV to VI rated local scaling, erythema, dryness, and stinging/burning as “none” in the study.¹⁵ Another potentially helpful topical agent in patients with AD and AV is sulfacetamide, as it is not likely to cause dryness of the skin. In a small study, sodium sulfacetamide 10% and sulfur 5% in an emollient foam vehicle showed no residual film or sulfur smell and resulted in acne reduction of 50%.¹⁶

Patients with skin of color often experience PIH in AD and acne or hypopigmentation from inflammatory dermatoses including AD.^17,18 In addition to the dryness from AD and topical retinoid use, patients with skin of color may develop irritant contact dermatitis, thus leading to PIH.¹³ Dryness and irritant contact dermatitis also can be seen with the use of benzoyl peroxide in black patients. Because of these effects, gentle moisturizers are recommended, and both benzoyl peroxide and retinoids should be initiated at lower doses in patients with skin of color.¹³

For patients with severe nodulocystic acne, isotretinoin is the treatment of choice in patients with skin of color,¹³ but there is a dearth of clinical studies addressing complications seen in black adolescents on this treatment, especially with respect to those with AD. Of note, systemic antibiotics typically are initiated before isotretinoin; however, this strategy is falling out of favor due to concern for antibiotic resistance with long-term use.¹⁹

Impact of Athletics on AD in Black Adolescents

Because of the exacerbating effects of perspiration and heat causing itch and irritation in patients with AD, it is frequently advised that pediatric patients limit their participation in athletics because of the exacerbating effects of strenuous physical exercise on their disease.¹² In one study, 429 pediatric patients or their parents/guardians completed QOL questionnaires; 89% of patients 15 years and younger with severe AD reported that their disease was impacted by athletics and outdoor activities, and 86% of these pediatric patients with severe AD responded that their social lives and leisure activities were impacted.²⁰ Because adolescents often are involved in athletics or have mandatory physical education classes, AD may be isolating and may have a severe impact on self-esteem.

Aggressive treatment of AD with topical and systemic medications may be helpful in adolescents who may be reluctant to participate in sports because of teasing, bullying, or worsening of symptoms with heat or sweating.²¹ Now that dupilumab is available for adolescents, there is a chance that patients with severe and/or recalcitrant disease managed on this medication can achieve better control of their symptoms without the laboratory requirement of methotrexate and the difficulties of topical medication application, allowing them to engage in mandatory athletic classes as well as desired organized sports.

Use of Cosmetics for AD

Many adolescents experiment with cosmetics, and those with AD may use cosmetic products to cover hyperpigmented or hypopigmented lesions.¹⁸ In patients with active AD or increased sensitivity to allergens in cosmetic products, use of makeup can be a contributing factor for AD flares. Acne associated with cosmetics is especially important to consider in darker-skinned patients who may use makeup that is opaque and contains oil to conceal acne or PIH.

Allergens can be present in both cosmetics and pharmaceutical topical agents, and a Brazilian study found that approximately 89% of 813 prescription and nonprescription products (eg, topical drugs, sunscreens, moisturizers, soaps, cleansing lotions, shampoos, cosmeceuticals) contained allergens.²² Patients with AD have a higher prevalence of contact sensitization to fragrances, including balsam of Peru.²³ Some AD treatments that contain fragrances have caused further skin issues in a few patients. In one case series, 3 pediatric patients developed allergic contact dermatitis to Myroxylon pereirae (balsam of Peru) when using topical treatments for their AD, and their symptoms of scalp inflammation and alopecia resolved with discontinuation.²³

In a Dutch study, sensitization to Fragrance Mix I and M pereirae as well as other ingredients (eg, lanolin alcohol, Amerchol™ L 101 [a lanolin product]) was notably more common in pediatric patients with AD than in patients without AD; however, no data on patients with skin of color were included in this study.²⁴

Because of the increased risk of sensitization to fragrances and other ingredients in patients with AD as well as the high percentage of allergens in prescription and nonprescription products, it is important to discuss all personal care products that patients may be using, not just their cosmetic products. Also, patch testing may be helpful in determining true allergens in some patients. Patch testing is recommended for patients with treatment-resistant AD, and a recent study suggested it should be done prior to long-term use of immunosuppressive agents.²⁵ Increased steroid phobia and a push toward alternative medicines are leading both patients with AD and guardians of children with AD to look for other forms of moisturization, such as olive oil, coconut oil, sunflower seed oil, and shea butter, to decrease transepidermal water loss.^26,27 An important factor in AD treatment efficacy is patient acceptability in using what is recommended.²⁷ One study showed there was no difference in efficacy or acceptability in using a cream containing shea butter extract vs the ceramide-precursor product.²⁷ Current data show olive oil may exacerbate dry skin and AD,²⁶ and recommendation of any over-the-counter oils and butters in patients with AD should be made with great caution, as many of these products contain fragrances and other potential allergens.

Alternative Therapies for AD

Patients with AD often seek alternative or integrative treatment options, including dietary modifications and holistic remedies. Studies investigating the role of vitamins and supplements in treating AD are limited by sample size.²⁸ However, there is some evidence that may support supplementation with vitamins D and E in addressing AD symptoms. The use of probiotics in treating AD is controversial, but there are studies suggesting that the use of probiotics may prove beneficial in preventing infantile AD.²⁸ Additionally, findings from an ex vivo and in vitro study show that some conditions, including AD and acne, may benefit from the same probiotics, despite the differences in these two diseases. Both AD and acne have inflammatory and skin dysbiosis characteristics, which may be the common thread leading to both conditions potentially responding to treatment with probiotics.²⁹

Preliminary evidence indicates that supplements containing fatty acids such as docosahexaenoic acid, sea buckthorn oil, and hemp seed oil may decrease the severity of AD.²⁸ In a 20-week, randomized, single-blind, crossover study published in 2005, dietary hemp seed oil showed an improvement of clinical symptoms, including dry skin and itchiness, in patients with AD.³⁰

In light of recent legalization in several states, patients may turn to use of cannabinoid products to manage AD. In a systematic review, cannabinoid use was reportedly a therapeutic option in the treatment of AD and AV; however, the data are based on preclinical work, and there are no randomized, placebo-controlled studies to support the use of cannabinoids.³¹ Furthermore, there is great concern that use of these products in adolescents is an even larger unknown.

Final Thoughts

Eighty percent of children diagnosed with AD experience symptom improvement before their early teens³²; for those with AD during their preteen and teenage years, there can be psychological ramifications, as teenagers with AD report having fewer friends, are less socially involved, participate in fewer sports, and are absent from classes more often than their peers.⁵ In black patients with AD, school absences are even more common.⁶ Given the social and emotional impact of AD on patients with skin of color, it is imperative to treat the condition appropriately.³³ There are areas of opportunity for further research on alternate dosing of existing treatments for AV in patients with AD, further recommendations for adolescent athletes with AD, and which cosmetic and alternative medicine products may be beneficial for this population to improve their QOL.

Providers should discuss medical management in a broader context considering patients’ extracurricular activities, treatment vehicle preferences, expectations, and personal care habits. It also is important to address the many possible factors that may influence treatment adherence early on, particularly in adolescents, as these could be barriers to treatment. This article highlights considerations for treating AD and comorbid conditions that may further complicate treatment in adolescent patients with skin of color. The information provided should serve as a guide in initial counseling and management of AD in adolescents with skin of color.

Data are limited on the management of atopic dermatitis (AD) in adolescents, particularly in patients with skin of color, making it important to identify factors that may improve AD management in this population. Comorbid conditions (eg, acne, postinflammatory hyperpigmentation [PIH]), extracurricular activities (eg, athletics), and experimentation with cosmetics in adolescents, all of which can undermine treatment efficacy and medication adherence, make it particularly challenging to devise a therapeutic regimen in this patient population. We review the management of AD in black adolescents, with special consideration of concomitant treatment of acne vulgaris (AV) as well as lifestyle and social choices (Table).

Prevalence and Epidemiology

Atopic dermatitis affects 13% to 25% of children and 2% to 10% of adults.^1,2 Population‐based studies in the United States show a higher prevalence of AD in black children (19.3%) compared to European American (EA) children (16.1%).^3,4

AD in Black Adolescents

Atopic dermatitis is a common skin condition that is defined as a chronic, pruritic, inflammatory dermatosis with recurrent scaling, papules, and plaques (Figure) that usually develop during infancy and early childhood.³ Although AD severity improves for some patients in adolescence, it can be a lifelong issue affecting performance in academic and occupational settings.⁵ One US study of 8015 children found that there are racial and ethnic disparities in school absences among children (age range, 2–17 years) with AD, with children with skin of color being absent more often than white children.⁶ The same study noted that black children had a 1.5-fold higher chance of being absent 6 days over a 6-month school period compared to white children. It is postulated that AD has a greater impact on quality of life (QOL) in children with skin of color, resulting in the increased number of school absences in this population.⁶

The origin of AD currently is thought to be complex and can involve skin barrier dysfunction, environmental factors, microbiome effects, genetic predisposition, and immune dysregulation.^1,4 Atopic dermatitis is a heterogeneous disease with variations in the prevalence, genetic background, and immune activation patterns across racial groups.⁴ It is now understood to be an immune-mediated disease with multiple inflammatory pathways, with type 2–associated inflammation being a primary pathway. Patients with AD have strong helper T cell (T_H2) activation, and black patients with AD have higher IgE serum levels as well as absent T_H17/T_H1 activation.⁴

Atopic dermatitis currently is seen as a defect of the epidermal barrier, with variable clinical manifestations and expressivity.⁷ Filaggrin is an epidermal barrier protein, encoded by the FLG gene, and plays a major role in barrier function by regulating pH and promoting hydration of the skin.⁴ Loss of function of the FLG gene is the most well-studied genetic risk factor for developing AD, and this mutation is seen in patients with more severe and persistent AD in addition to patients with more skin infections and allergic sensitizations.^3,4 However, in the skin of color population, FLG mutations are 6 times less common than in the EA population, despite the fact that AD is more prevalent in patients of African descent.⁴ Therefore, the role of the FLG loss-of-function mutation and AD is not as well defined in black patients, and some researchers have found no association.³ The FLG loss-of-function mutation seems to play a smaller role in black patients than in EA patients, and other genes may be involved in skin barrier dysfunction.^3,4 In a small study of patients with mild AD compared to nonaffected patients, those with AD had lower total ceramide levels in the stratum corneum of affected sites than normal skin sites in healthy individuals.⁸

Particular disturbances in the gut microbiome have the possibility of impacting the development of AD.⁹ Additionally, the development of AD may be influenced by the skin microbiome, which can change depending on body site, with fungal organisms thought to make up a large proportion of the microbiome of patients with AD. In patients with AD, there is a lack of microbial diversity and an overgrowth of Staphylococcus aureus.⁹

Diagnosis

Clinicians diagnose AD based on clinical characteristics, and the lack of objective criteria can hinder diagnosis.¹ Thus, diagnosing AD in children with dark skin can pose a particular challenge given the varied clinical presentation of AD across skin types. Severe cases of AD may not be diagnosed or treated adequately in deeply pigmented children because erythema, a defining characteristic of AD, may be hard to identify in darker skin types.¹⁰ Furthermore, clinical erythema scores among black children may be “strongly” underestimated using scoring systems such as Eczema Area and Severity Index and SCORing Atopic Dermatitis.⁴ It is estimated that the risk for severe AD may be 6 times higher in black children compared to white children.¹⁰ Additionally, patients with skin of color can present with more treatment-resistant AD.⁴

Treatment of AD

Current treatment is focused on restoring epidermal barrier function, often with topical agents, such as moisturizers containing different amounts of emollients, occlusives, and humectants; corticosteroids; calcineurin inhibitors; and antimicrobials. Emollients such as glycol stearate, glyceryl stearate, and soy sterols function as lubricants, softening the skin. Occlusive agents include petrolatum, dimethicone, and mineral oil; they act by forming a layer to slow evaporation of water. Humectants including glycerol, lactic acid, and urea function by promoting water retention.¹¹ For acute flares, mid- to high-potency topical corticosteroids are recommended. Also, topical calcineurin inhibitors such as tacrolimus and pimecrolimus may be used alone or in combination with topical steroids. Finally, bleach baths and topical mupirocin applied to the nares also have proved helpful in moderate to severe AD with secondary bacterial infections.¹¹ Phototherapy can be used in adult and pediatric patients with acute and chronic AD if traditional treatments have failed.²

Systemic agents are indicated and recommended for the subset of adult and pediatric patients in whom optimized topical regimens and/or phototherapy do not adequately provide disease control or when QOL is substantially impacted. The systemic agents effective in the pediatric population include cyclosporine, azathioprine, mycophenolate mofetil, and possibly methotrexate.¹¹ Dupilumab recently was approved by the US Food and Drug Administration for patients 12 years and older with moderate to severe AD whose disease is not well controlled with topical medications.

Patients with AD are predisposed to secondary bacterial and viral infections because of their dysfunctional skin barrier; these infections most commonly are caused by S aureus and herpes simplex virus, respectively.² Systemic antibiotics are only recommended for patients with AD when there is clinical evidence of bacterial infection. In patients with evidence of eczema herpeticum, systemic antiviral agents should be used to treat the underlying herpes simplex virus infection.² Atopic dermatitis typically has been studied in white patients; however, patients with skin of color have higher frequencies of treatment-resistant AD. Further research on treatment efficacy for AD in this patient population is needed, as data are limited.⁴

Treatment of AV in Patients With AD

Two of the most prevalent skin diseases affecting the pediatric population are AD and AV, and both can remarkably impact QOL.¹² Acne is one of the most common reasons for adolescent patients to seek dermatologic care, including patients with skin of color (Fitzpatrick skin types IV to VI).¹³ Thus, it is to be expected that many black adolescents with AD also will have AV. For mild to moderate acne in patients with skin of color, topical retinoids and benzoyl peroxide typically are first line.¹³ These medications can be problematic for patients with AD, as retinoids and many other acne treatments can cause dryness, which may exacerbate AD.

Moisturizers containing ceramide can be a helpful adjunctive therapy in treating acne,¹⁴ especially in patients with AD. Modifications to application of acne medications, such as using topical retinoids every other night or mixing them with moisturizers to minimize dryness, may be beneficial to these patients. Dapsone gel 7.5% used daily also may be an option for adolescents with AD and AV. A double-blind, vehicle-controlled study demonstrated that dapsone is safe and effective for patients 12 years and older with moderate acne, and patients with Fitzpatrick skin types IV to VI rated local scaling, erythema, dryness, and stinging/burning as “none” in the study.¹⁵ Another potentially helpful topical agent in patients with AD and AV is sulfacetamide, as it is not likely to cause dryness of the skin. In a small study, sodium sulfacetamide 10% and sulfur 5% in an emollient foam vehicle showed no residual film or sulfur smell and resulted in acne reduction of 50%.¹⁶

Patients with skin of color often experience PIH in AD and acne or hypopigmentation from inflammatory dermatoses including AD.^17,18 In addition to the dryness from AD and topical retinoid use, patients with skin of color may develop irritant contact dermatitis, thus leading to PIH.¹³ Dryness and irritant contact dermatitis also can be seen with the use of benzoyl peroxide in black patients. Because of these effects, gentle moisturizers are recommended, and both benzoyl peroxide and retinoids should be initiated at lower doses in patients with skin of color.¹³

For patients with severe nodulocystic acne, isotretinoin is the treatment of choice in patients with skin of color,¹³ but there is a dearth of clinical studies addressing complications seen in black adolescents on this treatment, especially with respect to those with AD. Of note, systemic antibiotics typically are initiated before isotretinoin; however, this strategy is falling out of favor due to concern for antibiotic resistance with long-term use.¹⁹

Impact of Athletics on AD in Black Adolescents

Because of the exacerbating effects of perspiration and heat causing itch and irritation in patients with AD, it is frequently advised that pediatric patients limit their participation in athletics because of the exacerbating effects of strenuous physical exercise on their disease.¹² In one study, 429 pediatric patients or their parents/guardians completed QOL questionnaires; 89% of patients 15 years and younger with severe AD reported that their disease was impacted by athletics and outdoor activities, and 86% of these pediatric patients with severe AD responded that their social lives and leisure activities were impacted.²⁰ Because adolescents often are involved in athletics or have mandatory physical education classes, AD may be isolating and may have a severe impact on self-esteem.

Aggressive treatment of AD with topical and systemic medications may be helpful in adolescents who may be reluctant to participate in sports because of teasing, bullying, or worsening of symptoms with heat or sweating.²¹ Now that dupilumab is available for adolescents, there is a chance that patients with severe and/or recalcitrant disease managed on this medication can achieve better control of their symptoms without the laboratory requirement of methotrexate and the difficulties of topical medication application, allowing them to engage in mandatory athletic classes as well as desired organized sports.

Use of Cosmetics for AD

Many adolescents experiment with cosmetics, and those with AD may use cosmetic products to cover hyperpigmented or hypopigmented lesions.¹⁸ In patients with active AD or increased sensitivity to allergens in cosmetic products, use of makeup can be a contributing factor for AD flares. Acne associated with cosmetics is especially important to consider in darker-skinned patients who may use makeup that is opaque and contains oil to conceal acne or PIH.

Allergens can be present in both cosmetics and pharmaceutical topical agents, and a Brazilian study found that approximately 89% of 813 prescription and nonprescription products (eg, topical drugs, sunscreens, moisturizers, soaps, cleansing lotions, shampoos, cosmeceuticals) contained allergens.²² Patients with AD have a higher prevalence of contact sensitization to fragrances, including balsam of Peru.²³ Some AD treatments that contain fragrances have caused further skin issues in a few patients. In one case series, 3 pediatric patients developed allergic contact dermatitis to Myroxylon pereirae (balsam of Peru) when using topical treatments for their AD, and their symptoms of scalp inflammation and alopecia resolved with discontinuation.²³

In a Dutch study, sensitization to Fragrance Mix I and M pereirae as well as other ingredients (eg, lanolin alcohol, Amerchol™ L 101 [a lanolin product]) was notably more common in pediatric patients with AD than in patients without AD; however, no data on patients with skin of color were included in this study.²⁴

Because of the increased risk of sensitization to fragrances and other ingredients in patients with AD as well as the high percentage of allergens in prescription and nonprescription products, it is important to discuss all personal care products that patients may be using, not just their cosmetic products. Also, patch testing may be helpful in determining true allergens in some patients. Patch testing is recommended for patients with treatment-resistant AD, and a recent study suggested it should be done prior to long-term use of immunosuppressive agents.²⁵ Increased steroid phobia and a push toward alternative medicines are leading both patients with AD and guardians of children with AD to look for other forms of moisturization, such as olive oil, coconut oil, sunflower seed oil, and shea butter, to decrease transepidermal water loss.^26,27 An important factor in AD treatment efficacy is patient acceptability in using what is recommended.²⁷ One study showed there was no difference in efficacy or acceptability in using a cream containing shea butter extract vs the ceramide-precursor product.²⁷ Current data show olive oil may exacerbate dry skin and AD,²⁶ and recommendation of any over-the-counter oils and butters in patients with AD should be made with great caution, as many of these products contain fragrances and other potential allergens.

Alternative Therapies for AD

Patients with AD often seek alternative or integrative treatment options, including dietary modifications and holistic remedies. Studies investigating the role of vitamins and supplements in treating AD are limited by sample size.²⁸ However, there is some evidence that may support supplementation with vitamins D and E in addressing AD symptoms. The use of probiotics in treating AD is controversial, but there are studies suggesting that the use of probiotics may prove beneficial in preventing infantile AD.²⁸ Additionally, findings from an ex vivo and in vitro study show that some conditions, including AD and acne, may benefit from the same probiotics, despite the differences in these two diseases. Both AD and acne have inflammatory and skin dysbiosis characteristics, which may be the common thread leading to both conditions potentially responding to treatment with probiotics.²⁹

Preliminary evidence indicates that supplements containing fatty acids such as docosahexaenoic acid, sea buckthorn oil, and hemp seed oil may decrease the severity of AD.²⁸ In a 20-week, randomized, single-blind, crossover study published in 2005, dietary hemp seed oil showed an improvement of clinical symptoms, including dry skin and itchiness, in patients with AD.³⁰

In light of recent legalization in several states, patients may turn to use of cannabinoid products to manage AD. In a systematic review, cannabinoid use was reportedly a therapeutic option in the treatment of AD and AV; however, the data are based on preclinical work, and there are no randomized, placebo-controlled studies to support the use of cannabinoids.³¹ Furthermore, there is great concern that use of these products in adolescents is an even larger unknown.

Final Thoughts

Eighty percent of children diagnosed with AD experience symptom improvement before their early teens³²; for those with AD during their preteen and teenage years, there can be psychological ramifications, as teenagers with AD report having fewer friends, are less socially involved, participate in fewer sports, and are absent from classes more often than their peers.⁵ In black patients with AD, school absences are even more common.⁶ Given the social and emotional impact of AD on patients with skin of color, it is imperative to treat the condition appropriately.³³ There are areas of opportunity for further research on alternate dosing of existing treatments for AV in patients with AD, further recommendations for adolescent athletes with AD, and which cosmetic and alternative medicine products may be beneficial for this population to improve their QOL.

Providers should discuss medical management in a broader context considering patients’ extracurricular activities, treatment vehicle preferences, expectations, and personal care habits. It also is important to address the many possible factors that may influence treatment adherence early on, particularly in adolescents, as these could be barriers to treatment. This article highlights considerations for treating AD and comorbid conditions that may further complicate treatment in adolescent patients with skin of color. The information provided should serve as a guide in initial counseling and management of AD in adolescents with skin of color.