User login
Recertification will include physicians who were initially board certified with UCNS in the subspecialties of autonomic disorders, behavioral neurology and neuropsychiatry, clinical neuromuscular pathology, geriatric neurology, headache medicine, neurocritical care, neuroimaging, and neuro-oncology.
In 2020, UCNS transitioned to a new continuous-certification (C-cert) model that requires its diplomates to pay an annual fee of $175 and complete a 25-question online quiz based on preselected journal articles with an 80% passing grade. In a press release outlining the details of the new C-cert program, UCNS said that diplomates began the transition last year by “attesting they have participated in subspecialty-specific continuing medical education (CME) requirements from the time their most recent certificate was issued through 2019.” Diplomates have a 2-year window, which began in 2019, to meet these transitional CME requirements and complete an attestation statement before their certification lapses. “Diplomates with a status of ‘meeting requirements’ will be issued a replacement certificate that shows their original certification date and will reflect there is no expiration date after they pay the first annual C-cert fee in 2020,” UCNS said in the press release.
“It is unfortunate that despite requests from diplomates and other stakeholders, UCNS has decided to impose new requirements and additional fees on diplomates who have unexpired certificates based on passing an examination that granted a 10-year certification,” Paul G. Mathew, MD, assistant professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School in Boston and Director of Legislative Affairs at NBPAS, said in an interview. “A one-size-fits-all approach for learning with preselected articles is not ideal, and physicians should be able to choose CME and other learning activities that best suit their individual interests and practice.”
The added requirements and fees have caused some UCNS diplomates to consider letting their certification lapse, Dr. Mathew said, but the NBPAS decision offers them a new path to recertification. “Many physicians who would have otherwise let their certification lapse and would no longer be considered board certified in headache medicine and other UCNS subspecialties will now have the option to recertify with NBPAS,” he said.
NBPAS was formed in 2014 in response to controversial American Board of Medical Specialties Maintenance of Certification (MOC) programs. NBPAS recertifies diplomates of all specialties and subspecialties offered by the ABMS and its member boards, including board certification in neurology and neurologic subspecialties offered by the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology.
Board recertification with NBPAS requires an unrestricted license to practice medicine in the United States, an initial certification with ABPN, the American Osteopathic Association, and/or UCNS, a medical staff appointment/membership in good standing, active hospital privileges based on specialty, and 50 hours of relevant CME credits every 2 years.
“Although MOC compliance is not required for licensure, the vast majority of insurance carriers in the United States require to some extent that their physicians be MOC compliant. As such, the ABMS has a monopoly in that a physician cannot practice medicine without complying with MOC,” Dr. Mathew said. “That’s very gradually changing.”
So far, 13 states have passed legislation limiting ABMS MOC compliance as a requirement for credentialing or licensure, and 136 healthcare institutions have recognized NBPAS as a pathway for physician credentialing, according to an NBPAS press release.
Changing the rules
Alan Rapoport, MD, was asked to comment on the recertification situtaion. Dr. Rapoport is clinical professor of neurology at UCLA and the Editor in Chief of Neurology Reviews. “As Dr. Mathew aptly states, it is unfortunate that despite requests from diplomates and other stakeholders, UCNS has decided to impose new requirements and additional fees on diplomates who have unexpired certificates based on passing an examination that granted a 10-year certification,”
For context, Dr. Rapoport explained what has happened to him and about 200 neurologists and a few other specialists who took the first UCNS certifying exam in Headache Medicine. “I sat for the first exam in a testing center in 2006, after paying a large fee. I passed and was granted a certificate for a 10-year certification in Headache Medicine. Prior to the expiration of that certificate, I was told I had to pay about $1,800 and take a similar examination to certify for another 10 years. I was not sure I needed to do that, but I did so anyway and passed and was granted a new, dated certificate for another 10 years of certification in Headache Medicine. Shortly after that I began to get notices from UCNS saying that they were changing their certification process and I would soon have to read their designated articles, take an examination on that literature, pay $175 for this privilege of C-Cert yearly, all in spite of the fact that I had a valid certificate for 10 years of certification.”
After complaints from Dr. Rapoport and many others, “UCNS said we would only have to do this when we had 5 years left on our certification. When they advertised this new C-Cert plan on the AAN Headache Listserv, even though advertising was against the rules of the Listserv, I complained about it saying we had paid for a 10-year certification. Their response was to abruptly take me off the Listserv. Then they temporarily shut it down when others agreed with what I had written.”
Dr. Rapoport has the certificate that proves that he has 6 years left on his certification, but UCNS will not recognize this, he said. “I believe that to be unfair, unethical, and probably illegal, as do many senior Headache specialists in the country who have the same issue. The attorney for the UCNS, who is also the attorney for the AAN, has disregarded our objections to this move.”
Now the NBPAS will be recertifying Headache Medicine doctors and those of other specialties who are in a similar situation and do not want to pay for the privilege of taking exams yearly when they have already been certified. “I expect many specialists will switch to this new way of certifying,” Dr. Rapoport said.
“I believe the UCNS has cheapened the value of their certifications by not honoring them,” Dr. Rapoort said.
Dr. Mathew reports that he collects no salary for his role with NBPAS, but receives reimbursement for travel expenses, and occasionally receives honoraria for speaking on behalf of NBPAS.
Recertification will include physicians who were initially board certified with UCNS in the subspecialties of autonomic disorders, behavioral neurology and neuropsychiatry, clinical neuromuscular pathology, geriatric neurology, headache medicine, neurocritical care, neuroimaging, and neuro-oncology.
In 2020, UCNS transitioned to a new continuous-certification (C-cert) model that requires its diplomates to pay an annual fee of $175 and complete a 25-question online quiz based on preselected journal articles with an 80% passing grade. In a press release outlining the details of the new C-cert program, UCNS said that diplomates began the transition last year by “attesting they have participated in subspecialty-specific continuing medical education (CME) requirements from the time their most recent certificate was issued through 2019.” Diplomates have a 2-year window, which began in 2019, to meet these transitional CME requirements and complete an attestation statement before their certification lapses. “Diplomates with a status of ‘meeting requirements’ will be issued a replacement certificate that shows their original certification date and will reflect there is no expiration date after they pay the first annual C-cert fee in 2020,” UCNS said in the press release.
“It is unfortunate that despite requests from diplomates and other stakeholders, UCNS has decided to impose new requirements and additional fees on diplomates who have unexpired certificates based on passing an examination that granted a 10-year certification,” Paul G. Mathew, MD, assistant professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School in Boston and Director of Legislative Affairs at NBPAS, said in an interview. “A one-size-fits-all approach for learning with preselected articles is not ideal, and physicians should be able to choose CME and other learning activities that best suit their individual interests and practice.”
The added requirements and fees have caused some UCNS diplomates to consider letting their certification lapse, Dr. Mathew said, but the NBPAS decision offers them a new path to recertification. “Many physicians who would have otherwise let their certification lapse and would no longer be considered board certified in headache medicine and other UCNS subspecialties will now have the option to recertify with NBPAS,” he said.
NBPAS was formed in 2014 in response to controversial American Board of Medical Specialties Maintenance of Certification (MOC) programs. NBPAS recertifies diplomates of all specialties and subspecialties offered by the ABMS and its member boards, including board certification in neurology and neurologic subspecialties offered by the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology.
Board recertification with NBPAS requires an unrestricted license to practice medicine in the United States, an initial certification with ABPN, the American Osteopathic Association, and/or UCNS, a medical staff appointment/membership in good standing, active hospital privileges based on specialty, and 50 hours of relevant CME credits every 2 years.
“Although MOC compliance is not required for licensure, the vast majority of insurance carriers in the United States require to some extent that their physicians be MOC compliant. As such, the ABMS has a monopoly in that a physician cannot practice medicine without complying with MOC,” Dr. Mathew said. “That’s very gradually changing.”
So far, 13 states have passed legislation limiting ABMS MOC compliance as a requirement for credentialing or licensure, and 136 healthcare institutions have recognized NBPAS as a pathway for physician credentialing, according to an NBPAS press release.
Changing the rules
Alan Rapoport, MD, was asked to comment on the recertification situtaion. Dr. Rapoport is clinical professor of neurology at UCLA and the Editor in Chief of Neurology Reviews. “As Dr. Mathew aptly states, it is unfortunate that despite requests from diplomates and other stakeholders, UCNS has decided to impose new requirements and additional fees on diplomates who have unexpired certificates based on passing an examination that granted a 10-year certification,”
For context, Dr. Rapoport explained what has happened to him and about 200 neurologists and a few other specialists who took the first UCNS certifying exam in Headache Medicine. “I sat for the first exam in a testing center in 2006, after paying a large fee. I passed and was granted a certificate for a 10-year certification in Headache Medicine. Prior to the expiration of that certificate, I was told I had to pay about $1,800 and take a similar examination to certify for another 10 years. I was not sure I needed to do that, but I did so anyway and passed and was granted a new, dated certificate for another 10 years of certification in Headache Medicine. Shortly after that I began to get notices from UCNS saying that they were changing their certification process and I would soon have to read their designated articles, take an examination on that literature, pay $175 for this privilege of C-Cert yearly, all in spite of the fact that I had a valid certificate for 10 years of certification.”
After complaints from Dr. Rapoport and many others, “UCNS said we would only have to do this when we had 5 years left on our certification. When they advertised this new C-Cert plan on the AAN Headache Listserv, even though advertising was against the rules of the Listserv, I complained about it saying we had paid for a 10-year certification. Their response was to abruptly take me off the Listserv. Then they temporarily shut it down when others agreed with what I had written.”
Dr. Rapoport has the certificate that proves that he has 6 years left on his certification, but UCNS will not recognize this, he said. “I believe that to be unfair, unethical, and probably illegal, as do many senior Headache specialists in the country who have the same issue. The attorney for the UCNS, who is also the attorney for the AAN, has disregarded our objections to this move.”
Now the NBPAS will be recertifying Headache Medicine doctors and those of other specialties who are in a similar situation and do not want to pay for the privilege of taking exams yearly when they have already been certified. “I expect many specialists will switch to this new way of certifying,” Dr. Rapoport said.
“I believe the UCNS has cheapened the value of their certifications by not honoring them,” Dr. Rapoort said.
Dr. Mathew reports that he collects no salary for his role with NBPAS, but receives reimbursement for travel expenses, and occasionally receives honoraria for speaking on behalf of NBPAS.
Recertification will include physicians who were initially board certified with UCNS in the subspecialties of autonomic disorders, behavioral neurology and neuropsychiatry, clinical neuromuscular pathology, geriatric neurology, headache medicine, neurocritical care, neuroimaging, and neuro-oncology.
In 2020, UCNS transitioned to a new continuous-certification (C-cert) model that requires its diplomates to pay an annual fee of $175 and complete a 25-question online quiz based on preselected journal articles with an 80% passing grade. In a press release outlining the details of the new C-cert program, UCNS said that diplomates began the transition last year by “attesting they have participated in subspecialty-specific continuing medical education (CME) requirements from the time their most recent certificate was issued through 2019.” Diplomates have a 2-year window, which began in 2019, to meet these transitional CME requirements and complete an attestation statement before their certification lapses. “Diplomates with a status of ‘meeting requirements’ will be issued a replacement certificate that shows their original certification date and will reflect there is no expiration date after they pay the first annual C-cert fee in 2020,” UCNS said in the press release.
“It is unfortunate that despite requests from diplomates and other stakeholders, UCNS has decided to impose new requirements and additional fees on diplomates who have unexpired certificates based on passing an examination that granted a 10-year certification,” Paul G. Mathew, MD, assistant professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School in Boston and Director of Legislative Affairs at NBPAS, said in an interview. “A one-size-fits-all approach for learning with preselected articles is not ideal, and physicians should be able to choose CME and other learning activities that best suit their individual interests and practice.”
The added requirements and fees have caused some UCNS diplomates to consider letting their certification lapse, Dr. Mathew said, but the NBPAS decision offers them a new path to recertification. “Many physicians who would have otherwise let their certification lapse and would no longer be considered board certified in headache medicine and other UCNS subspecialties will now have the option to recertify with NBPAS,” he said.
NBPAS was formed in 2014 in response to controversial American Board of Medical Specialties Maintenance of Certification (MOC) programs. NBPAS recertifies diplomates of all specialties and subspecialties offered by the ABMS and its member boards, including board certification in neurology and neurologic subspecialties offered by the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology.
Board recertification with NBPAS requires an unrestricted license to practice medicine in the United States, an initial certification with ABPN, the American Osteopathic Association, and/or UCNS, a medical staff appointment/membership in good standing, active hospital privileges based on specialty, and 50 hours of relevant CME credits every 2 years.
“Although MOC compliance is not required for licensure, the vast majority of insurance carriers in the United States require to some extent that their physicians be MOC compliant. As such, the ABMS has a monopoly in that a physician cannot practice medicine without complying with MOC,” Dr. Mathew said. “That’s very gradually changing.”
So far, 13 states have passed legislation limiting ABMS MOC compliance as a requirement for credentialing or licensure, and 136 healthcare institutions have recognized NBPAS as a pathway for physician credentialing, according to an NBPAS press release.
Changing the rules
Alan Rapoport, MD, was asked to comment on the recertification situtaion. Dr. Rapoport is clinical professor of neurology at UCLA and the Editor in Chief of Neurology Reviews. “As Dr. Mathew aptly states, it is unfortunate that despite requests from diplomates and other stakeholders, UCNS has decided to impose new requirements and additional fees on diplomates who have unexpired certificates based on passing an examination that granted a 10-year certification,”
For context, Dr. Rapoport explained what has happened to him and about 200 neurologists and a few other specialists who took the first UCNS certifying exam in Headache Medicine. “I sat for the first exam in a testing center in 2006, after paying a large fee. I passed and was granted a certificate for a 10-year certification in Headache Medicine. Prior to the expiration of that certificate, I was told I had to pay about $1,800 and take a similar examination to certify for another 10 years. I was not sure I needed to do that, but I did so anyway and passed and was granted a new, dated certificate for another 10 years of certification in Headache Medicine. Shortly after that I began to get notices from UCNS saying that they were changing their certification process and I would soon have to read their designated articles, take an examination on that literature, pay $175 for this privilege of C-Cert yearly, all in spite of the fact that I had a valid certificate for 10 years of certification.”
After complaints from Dr. Rapoport and many others, “UCNS said we would only have to do this when we had 5 years left on our certification. When they advertised this new C-Cert plan on the AAN Headache Listserv, even though advertising was against the rules of the Listserv, I complained about it saying we had paid for a 10-year certification. Their response was to abruptly take me off the Listserv. Then they temporarily shut it down when others agreed with what I had written.”
Dr. Rapoport has the certificate that proves that he has 6 years left on his certification, but UCNS will not recognize this, he said. “I believe that to be unfair, unethical, and probably illegal, as do many senior Headache specialists in the country who have the same issue. The attorney for the UCNS, who is also the attorney for the AAN, has disregarded our objections to this move.”
Now the NBPAS will be recertifying Headache Medicine doctors and those of other specialties who are in a similar situation and do not want to pay for the privilege of taking exams yearly when they have already been certified. “I expect many specialists will switch to this new way of certifying,” Dr. Rapoport said.
“I believe the UCNS has cheapened the value of their certifications by not honoring them,” Dr. Rapoort said.
Dr. Mathew reports that he collects no salary for his role with NBPAS, but receives reimbursement for travel expenses, and occasionally receives honoraria for speaking on behalf of NBPAS.